Pull to refresh
Logo
Illinois regulators slash Peoples Gas rate increase and hold the 2035 pipe deadline

Illinois regulators slash Peoples Gas rate increase and hold the 2035 pipe deadline

Rule Changes Chicago, IL local

The commission approved $40.3 million of a $144 million request and trimmed the utility's requested profit margin

Overview

Updated 14 hours ago

Peoples Gas asked Illinois regulators for $202 million more from Chicago households each year. On Nov. 19, the Illinois Commerce Commission gave the utility $40.3 million.

The commission cut the utility's requested return on equity from 10.10% to 9.48%. It kept the 2035 deadline for retiring 1,020 miles of gas main, a program that began about 15 years ago and runs years behind schedule and billions over budget. Peoples Gas says the order strips $25 million from what it calls critical day-to-day safety work.

Why it matters

Nearly one in five Chicago gas customers was behind on bills in September; their January increase will be smaller than the utility wanted.

Last Monday's email for Chicago, IL

Sent Nov 16. It carried:

Get next Monday's: one short email a week. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

$40.3M
Rate increase approved
The amount the Illinois Commerce Commission authorized, effective for January bills.
$144M
Amount Peoples Gas requested
Down from the $202 million the utility sought in January 2026.
1,020 mi
Pipe slated for retirement
Miles of aging gas main the commission still expects replaced by 2035.
9.48%
Approved return on equity
Cut from the 10.10% Peoples Gas requested.
~20%
Customers 30+ days behind on bills
State data as of September 2026, cited by consumer advocates.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

People Involved

Organizations Involved

Timeline

2023 November 2026

6 events Latest: Yesterday
Tap a bar to jump to that date
  1. Commission approves $40.3 million

    Latest Regulation

    Regulators cut more than $103 million from the request, lower the return on equity and keep the 2035 pipe deadline.

  2. Advocates deliver 10,000+ comments

    Protest

    Consumer and environmental groups carry petitions to a commission meeting in Chicago.

  3. Judges recommend $66.2 million

    Regulation

    Commission administrative law judges propose a far smaller increase than the utility sought.

  4. Peoples Gas asks for $202 million

    Filing

    The utility opens its rate case; the attorney general calls the request unsupported and unexplained.

  5. Request trimmed to $144 million

    Filing

    Peoples Gas cuts $58 million from its ask over the summer.

  6. Record increase approved

    Regulation

    The Illinois Commerce Commission grants Peoples Gas a $306 million increase, its largest at the time.

Scenarios

1

Peoples Gas Files Another Rate Case Within a Year

Likely Resolves by Q2 2027

Discussed by: Consumer advocates and the commission's own ratemaking record, which shows successive annual requests

The utility has returned to the commission repeatedly as pipe replacement costs accumulate. A $40.3 million increase leaves its approved revenue far below what it says the work requires, which gives it an incentive to file again rather than absorb the gap. A new filing would reopen the same dispute over how much of the program customers fund.

2

Regulators Shrink the Pipe Mandate Before 2035

Possible Resolves by End of 2027

Discussed by: Illinois PIRG, the Citizens Utility Board and other commenters who asked the commission to end or restructure the program

Advocates want the commission to stop treating 1,020 miles as fixed and to prioritize the leakiest pipe instead. The commission kept the mandate this time. A later order could narrow the scope or stretch the deadline if costs keep climbing or if a management audit finds the program unworkable.

3

Illinois Lawmakers Rewrite the Pipe Program

Unlikely Resolves by Q2 2027

Discussed by: Consumer and environmental advocates who have taken the fight beyond the commission

The commission's authority over the program comes from statute and prior orders, so advocates who lose there can go to the General Assembly. A bill could change the replacement standard, add cost caps or shift funding. Any such measure would need to clear both chambers in Springfield and be signed by the governor.

Historical Context

2 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

September 2010

San Bruno pipeline explosion (2010)

A Pacific Gas and Electric transmission pipeline ruptured beneath a residential street in San Bruno, California, sending a fireball through the neighborhood. Eight people were killed and dozens of homes were destroyed. Investigators traced the failure to a defective seam weld on pipe installed decades earlier.

Then

Federal and state regulators imposed new pipeline integrity rules and PG&E was later convicted on federal safety charges.

Now

The case became the standard reference for what deferred pipeline work can cost in lives, and it reshaped how states audit utility replacement programs.

Why this matters now

Peoples Gas argues the commission's cut removes money for safety work; San Bruno is the reason regulators treat that claim seriously even when they doubt the utility's cost estimates.

January 2019

PG&E bankruptcy (2019)

Facing liabilities from wildfires started by its equipment in 2017 and 2018, Pacific Gas and Electric filed for Chapter 11 protection. The filing followed years of criticism that the utility underinvested in maintaining and modernizing its system.

Then

The company reorganized under court supervision and emerged from bankruptcy in 2020 with new governance and safety oversight conditions.

Now

It showed that a utility's deferred maintenance can turn into a solvency problem, not just a service problem, and that customers end up paying either way.

Why this matters now

Chicago's dispute is about who pays for pipe replacement now, but the PG&E case is the backdrop for why neither the utility nor the commission wants to be the one that lets the work slip.

Sources

(3)