Pull to refresh
Logo
What Changed
Following Why Sign Up
Florida administrative judge lets doctors' groups join vaccine rule challenge

Florida administrative judge lets doctors' groups join vaccine rule challenge

Rule Changes

Two medical societies can argue against the state's plan to drop four school vaccine requirements before a December hearing

Yesterday: Judge lets pediatricians and internists intervene

Overview

Updated 53 minutes ago

Florida's Legislature requires seven childhood vaccines for school entry. Four more — chickenpox, hepatitis B, Hib and pneumococcal disease — rest on a Department of Health rule. The department wants to drop those four, and on Nov. 9 an administrative law judge let two medical societies join the fight against it.

The ruling is procedural, but it widens the group challenging the rollback before a hearing that starts Dec. 14. If Judge W. David Watkins upholds the change, the four requirements could lapse before Gov. Ron DeSantis leaves office on Jan. 5.

Why it matters

More than 3 million Florida students could enter school without four vaccines the state has required for years.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

4
Vaccines proposed for removal
Hib, hepatitis B, varicella and pneumococcal conjugate are required by rule, not statute.
7
Vaccines required by state law
Polio, diphtheria, measles, rubella, pertussis, mumps and tetanus would stay.
180
Rulemaking deadline
State law sets a 180-day limit for an agency to move from a public meeting to a proposed rule.
225
Days the petition says passed without progress
The family physicians' petition argues the department did nothing for 225 days.
3,000,000
Students covered by the rules
Public, private and preschool enrollment in Florida, per reporting on the dispute.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

Log in Sign Up

People Involved

WW
W. David Watkins
Administrative Law Judge, Florida Division of Administrative Hearings
Presiding over the consolidated vaccine rule challenge
 Joseph Ladapo
Joseph Ladapo
Florida Surgeon General and Secretary of the Department of Health
Leading the push to drop the four rule-based vaccine requirements
 Ron DeSantis
Ron DeSantis
Governor of Florida
Leaves office Jan. 5, 2027
CN
Christopher Nuland
Health care attorney representing the two intervening medical societies
Arguing for the pediatricians and internists to participate
 Danielle Carter
Danielle Carter
Jacksonville physician and petitioner
Plaintiff in the first consolidated challenge
KT
Kimberly Thorpe
Parent of medically fragile children and petitioner
Plaintiff in the second consolidated challenge

Organizations Involved

Florida Department of Health
Florida Department of Health
State agency
Proposing to drop four vaccine requirements and defending the rule in court

The agency writes the immunization rules that go beyond the seven vaccines the Legislature requires.
Florida Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics
Florida Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics
Professional medical society
Intervenor in the consolidated challenge

The state chapter of the national pediatricians' group, now a party arguing to keep the four requirements.
FC
Florida Chapter of the American College of Physicians Services
Professional medical society
Intervenor in the consolidated challenge

The state chapter of the internists' group, represented by the same attorney as the pediatricians.
FA
Florida Academy of Family Physicians
Professional medical society
Lead petitioner in the first challenge

The family physicians' group filed the October petition that opened the consolidated case.
Florida Division of Administrative Hearings
Florida Division of Administrative Hearings
State administrative court
Hearing the consolidated challenge

Florida's administrative court, which reviews whether agencies followed the law in writing rules.

Timeline

December 2025 November 2026

9 events Latest: Yesterday
Tap a bar to jump to that date

  1. Judge lets pediatricians and internists intervene

    Latest Legal

    Watkins denies the department's request to limit the number of plaintiffs and allows the two medical societies into the case.

  2. Judge consolidates cases, sets December hearing

    Legal

    Judge Watkins combines the two challenges and schedules arguments for the week of Dec. 14.

  3. Family physicians file challenge with administrative court

    Legal

    The Florida Academy of Family Physicians, Dr. Danielle Carter and two anonymous individuals petition the Division of Administrative Hearings.

  4. Second public meeting held in Lake Mary

    Public Meeting

    The department takes public comment on the revised rule.

  5. State drops moral exemption from proposal

    Rulemaking

    The department removes the proposed moral or ethical belief opt-out and announces an Oct. 8 meeting in Lake Mary.

  6. Department proposes rule to drop four vaccines

    Rulemaking

    The proposed rule tracks the existing immunization rule almost word for word, minus the four requirements.

  7. Second letter offers no reason for delay

    Procedure

    The petition later argues the department identified no cause for missing the 180-day rulemaking deadline.

  8. Department writes to rulemaking oversight committee

    Procedure

    First of two letters to the Joint Administrative Procedures Committee about the pending rule.

  9. Department opens rulemaking with Panama City meeting

    Public Meeting

    The Department of Health holds its first public meeting on removing the four vaccine requirements.

Scenarios

1

Judge upholds rollback; four requirements lapse before DeSantis leaves office

Possible Resolves by Jan 5, 2027

Discussed by: Christopher Nuland, attorney for the intervening medical societies, who told the Florida Phoenix the schedule could allow it

Watkins rules for the Department of Health after the December hearing, finding it followed rulemaking procedure and stayed within its authority. The rule is filed and takes effect before Jan. 5. The medical groups would then have to appeal.

2

Judge rejects rollback; four vaccine requirements stay

Possible Resolves by Q1 2027

Discussed by: The petitioners, who argue the department missed its deadline and exceeded its authority

Watkins finds the department missed the 180-day rulemaking limit without explanation, or that removing the requirements conflicts with its statutory duty to prevent communicable disease. The rule is invalidated and the four requirements remain in place.

3

Next administration restores the four requirements by rule

Uncertain Resolves by Nov 30, 2028

Discussed by: No named forecaster; this follows from the rule being an agency action rather than a statute

After DeSantis leaves office, a new governor's health department proposes a rule adding the four vaccines back. Because the requirements live in an administrative rule, restoring them would not need a legislative vote.

Historical Context

3 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

1905

Jacobson v. Massachusetts (1905)

During a smallpox outbreak, Cambridge required vaccination. Henning Jacobson refused and was fined $5. He argued the mandate violated his liberty.

Then

The Supreme Court upheld the mandate 7-2 and the fine stood.

Now

The ruling remains the foundation for state vaccine mandates and for the limits courts place on them.

Why this matters now

Florida's fight is about which branch sets vaccine policy, but the underlying state authority traces back to this case.

June 2019

New York ends religious exemption for school vaccines (2019)

Amid a measles outbreak centered in Orthodox Jewish communities, New York's Legislature voted to remove the religious exemption to school vaccination. Hundreds protested at the Capitol.

Then

The law took effect and unvaccinated children were barred from school.

Now

A federal appeals court upheld the repeal in 2021, and other states have since considered similar limits.

Why this matters now

It shows how quickly a state can change school vaccine rules, and the legal challenge that follows.

2026

Florida Legislature declines full repeal (2026)

Ladapo and DeSantis pushed to remove all vaccine mandates. No legislator filed a bill to do it in 2026. A 'Medical Freedom' bill expanding exemptions passed the Senate but died in the House.

Then

The seven statutory vaccines stayed in place.

Now

The department turned to the administrative rule, which it can change without the Legislature.

Why this matters now

It explains why this fight is in an administrative courtroom rather than at the Capitol.

Sources

(8)
+2
Florida Phoenix WUSF Chronicle Online CBS Miami Medical Daily Florida Trident Florida Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics WUSF