Pull to refresh
Logo
DME supplier regains Medicare billing after appeals board rejects contractor's revocation

DME supplier regains Medicare billing after appeals board rejects contractor's revocation

Rule Changes

Palmetto GBA pulled a supplier's enrollment over alleged standards violations. CMS dropped the reasoning and reinstated the privileges in full.

Overview

Updated 11 minutes ago

A durable medical equipment supplier lost its Medicare billing number after contractor Palmetto GBA said it failed supplier standards. On Nov. 19, the Department of Health and Human Services' Departmental Appeals Board restored it, after the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services conceded the contractor's reasoning was wrong.

Revocation cuts a supplier off from the program that pays for most home oxygen, wheelchairs and prosthetics. The decision follows an October appeals ruling in a separate case that limited what CMS can cite to justify a revocation, and it lands in the same week CMS proposed new screening rules for the same supplier pool.

Why it matters

When a Medicare contractor revokes a supplier's number, patients in that area lose a vendor for home oxygen, wheelchairs and prosthetics.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

60
Public comment days on the CRUSH rule
CMS proposed owner-screening and 30-day reporting requirements for Medicare enrollees on Nov. 16, 2026.
365
Length of the re-enrollment bar overturned in the 2025 case
Palmetto imposed a one-year ban alongside that revocation; a reconsideration contractor reversed both.
30
Notice period most revocations carried before the November 2026 rule
The new final rule lets revocations take effect retroactively, back to when the conduct began.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

Organizations Involved

Timeline

February 2025 November 2026

7 events Latest: 3 days ago
Tap a bar to jump to that date
  1. CMS proposes owner screening for Medicare enrollees

    Rulemaking

    The CRUSH rule, CMS-6098-P, would add owner screening and 30-day reporting duties, with 60 days of public comment.

  2. Final rule expands revocation timing

    Rulemaking

    CMS finalized changes letting revocations take retroactive effect, reaching back to when the conduct began.

Scenarios

1

Another DMEPOS revocation falls at the appeals board on sub-regulatory grounds

Likely Resolves by Q2 2027

Discussed by: VitalLaw's summaries of DAB decisions and Health Law Alliance's published case results

Suppliers are arguing that contractors enforced program manual provisions that the regulation never adopted. If a second judge follows the Manchester Urology reasoning, the pattern becomes a predictable route to reversal.

2

A court blocks the retroactive revocation effective dates

Uncertain Resolves by Q2 2027

Discussed by: Morgan Lewis's Health Law Scan analysis of the November 2026 final rule

The rule lets contractors reach back to the start of the noncompliance instead of the 30-day prospective window used before. A supplier or trade group could ask a federal court to stay that provision, arguing it changes the consequences of conduct already reviewed.

3

CMS finalizes owner screening and 30-day reporting

Possible Resolves by End of 2027

Discussed by: Health Law Alliance's summary of the CRUSH rule comment process

The CRUSH proposal opened a 60-day comment window in November 2026. If CMS finalizes it largely as proposed, every Medicare enrollee would face new disclosure duties on ownership changes within 30 days.

4

CMS rewrites the site-visit and insurance standards themselves

Unlikely Resolves by Q3 2027

Discussed by: No agency proposal exists; Health Law Alliance and Morgan Lewis are tracking the rule changes

Repeated losses at the ALJ level came from contractors enforcing manual provisions rather than the regulation. CMS could write those requirements into 42 C.F.R. § 424.57(c) so they survive appeal, which would end the current reversal route.

Historical Context

3 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

February–June 2025

'By appointment only' site visits (2025)

Palmetto revoked a DMEPOS supplier's billing privileges after contractors found a location closed during business hours, and added a one-year re-enrollment bar. The supplier was registered with CMS as appointment-only and had posted entry instructions on its door.

Then

The supplier filed for reconsideration, and on June 9, 2025 Chags Health Information Technology reversed both the revocation and the bar.

Now

Privileges were restored back to Feb. 20, 2025, the date of the improper visit, and the case became a template for later appeals.

Why this matters now

Same failure mode at an earlier stage: a revocation that fell apart once the contractor's own process was examined.

October 2026

Manchester Urology and manual guidance (2026)

CMS revoked a New Hampshire supplier's enrollment over three supplier standards, including a liability insurance certificate. A contractor said the certificate named the wrong policy holder, citing a Medicare Program Integrity Manual provision.

Then

An administrative law judge reversed, finding the insurance regulation did not require the contractor to be named as policy holder.

Now

The judge held that manual guidance can inform but cannot replace the regulation, and that no re-enrollment bar can stand without a valid revocation.

Why this matters now

Supplies the legal reasoning behind challenges like this one: contractor decisions have to rest on 42 C.F.R. § 424.57(c), not on internal instructions.

2020s

Contractor algorithms and DMEPOS fraud screening (2020s)

Federal agencies and their regional contractors built predictive models and data mining to flag billing anomalies in DMEPOS, a category the government treats as high risk for Medicare fraud.

Then

Flags feed referrals and site visits that can end in revocation of a supplier's enrollment.

Now

Suppliers challenge the resulting decisions one at a time through reconsideration and the appeals board.

Why this matters now

Explains the volume of revocation appeals: a model flags a supplier, a contractor acts, and a judge later checks the file.

Sources

(7)