Pull to refresh
Logo
Korean American mother sues In-N-Out over alleged failure to stop racist attack

Korean American mother sues In-N-Out over alleged failure to stop racist attack

Rule Changes Los Angeles, CA local

The suit says Sherman Oaks employees served the attacker and told the family police were coming. LAPD says no call was logged.

Overview

Updated 3 hours ago

Julie Choi took her 17-year-old daughter to the In-N-Out in Sherman Oaks in May to celebrate a finished history exam. A lawsuit filed Nov. 18 says a woman shoved the girl, called them anti-Asian slurs and poured soda on both of them, while a security guard stood between them and employees served the woman her food.

Choi says the manager told her police had been called. The Los Angeles Police Department says no call came from the restaurant that night. The suit, filed in Los Angeles County Superior Court, accuses the chain of failing to protect two customers and seeks damages for emotional distress and punitive damages.

Why it matters

The case asks how much a restaurant owes a customer being attacked by another customer, and whether calling police afterward is enough.

Last Monday's email for Los Angeles, CA

Sent Nov 16. It carried:

Get next Monday's: one short email a week. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

1
Civil lawsuits filed
Choi's complaint was filed Nov. 18, 2026, in Los Angeles County Superior Court.
0
Calls LAPD logged from the restaurant that night
A lieutenant confirmed no call came from the address; a battery report was logged nearby at 7:52 p.m.
$25
Gift card the manager gave the family
Choi says the manager handed it over while escorting them to their car.
~70
People Choi says were in the restaurant
She says no one intervened during the confrontation.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

People Involved

Organizations Involved

Timeline

May 2026 November 2026

4 events Latest: Yesterday
Tap a bar to jump to that date
  1. In-N-Out declines to comment on pending litigation

    Latest Statement

    Spokesperson Patty Peña cites ongoing litigation; LAPD confirms no call was logged.

  2. Woman attacks mother and daughter at Sherman Oaks In-N-Out

    Incident

    According to the suit, she shoved the 17-year-old, shouted slurs and poured soda on both.

Scenarios

1

In-N-Out settles with the Choi family before trial

Likely Resolves by End of 2027

Discussed by: Neither party has publicly forecast an outcome; In-N-Out has declined to comment and Choi's complaint seeks unspecified damages.

Suits over customer safety at chain restaurants usually end in a negotiated payment rather than a verdict, partly because a public trial would air internal staffing and security policies. A settlement would show up as a notice of settlement and a dismissal, and would set no public legal precedent. It would also mean the central factual dispute, whether employees acted reasonably, is never tested in court.

2

Case survives early challenges and moves into discovery

Possible Resolves by Q2 2027

Discussed by: No ruling has been issued; the question is whether a judge accepts the claim that In-N-Out had a duty that it breached.

The central legal fight is whether a restaurant can be held liable for the acts of one customer against another. In-N-Out is likely to argue that the attack was sudden and unforeseeable, which is the standard defense in third-party violence cases. Choi's side will point to the length of the confrontation, the guard's presence and the decision to serve the woman. If a judge lets the case proceed, internal records on security training and the surveillance footage Choi says the chain withheld would become discoverable.

3

Prosecutors file hate crime charges against the woman

Unlikely Resolves by Nov 30, 2027

Discussed by: LAPD told Choi the incident amounted to a hate crime, but six months have passed without an identification.

Police have circulated no description of a suspect and have not announced an arrest. Video from a bystander captured part of the confrontation, which could support an identification, but the case has been open since May. A charging decision would move the story from civil liability to criminal exposure and would give the lawsuit a named defendant to point to.

Historical Context

3 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

2022

Anti-Asian harassment at a Contra Costa In-N-Out (2022)

Two Korean American students from UCLA were recording a video at an In-N-Out in Contra Costa County when a man approached, asked about their ethnicity and made homophobic and racist remarks. He was arrested on two hate crime charges.

Then

The recording circulated widely and the man faced charges in Contra Costa County.

Now

The clip became one of several 2022 viral incidents that pushed anti-Asian harassment at everyday businesses into public discussion.

Why this matters now

It shows this is not the first time an In-N-Out restaurant has been the setting for an anti-Asian incident, which is part of why this suit has drawn attention.

2012-2016

Cinemark and the Aurora theater shooting lawsuits (2012-2016)

Survivors and the families of people killed in the 2012 Aurora, Colorado theater shooting sued Cinemark, arguing the chain should have done more to secure the building. A jury in 2016 found Cinemark not liable, concluding the attack was not foreseeable.

Then

The plaintiffs lost, and Cinemark also prevailed in a separate suit over the same shooting.

Now

The verdict illustrated how high the bar is: businesses are generally not held responsible for third-party violence unless the specific risk was known in advance.

Why this matters now

It marks the obstacle Choi's suit faces. Her case depends on convincing a judge that a prolonged, visible confrontation created a duty the staff failed to meet.

1994

Denny's racial discrimination settlements (1994)

After years of complaints that Black customers were refused service or required to prepay while white customers were not, Denny's settled a set of suits brought by the Department of Justice and private plaintiffs. The company agreed to a monitoring arrangement and to change how staff treated customers.

Then

The chain paid a settlement and accepted outside oversight of its restaurants.

Now

It became a reference point for holding restaurant chains accountable for how employees treat customers by race.

Why this matters now

It shows how these cases can end in changes to staff rules across a chain rather than a single payment to one family, which is what Choi says she wants.

Sources

(4)