Miss American Pie at 86 5th Ave (until October 2025)
Miss American Pie, a pie shop, held a New York liquor license at 86 5th Avenue. That license expired October 31, 2025, and the shop vacated the space.
The storefront at 86 5th Avenue sat empty of a licensed food-and-beverage business after the pie shop's departure.
The lapsed license opened the door for a new tenant to apply for its own approval at the same address.
It shows Lileo is taking over a space with a history of food and alcohol service, and explains the license gap the September 2026 approval fills.
