Pull to refresh
Logo
New York regulators approve National Grid gas rate freeze with costs deferred

New York regulators approve National Grid gas rate freeze with costs deferred

Rule Changes New York, NY local

The Public Service Commission backed a yearlong freeze for nearly 2 million gas customers; critics say $1.7 billion in planned spending will reach bills after it ends.

Overview

Updated 53 minutes ago

For nearly 2 million National Grid gas customers in New York City and on Long Island, the New York Public Service Commission (PSC) has approved a yearlong rate freeze that keeps bills at current levels through March 2028. The same decision lets the utility keep spending on its gas system and seek to recover about $1.7 billion of that spending from customers after the freeze ends.

The PSC approved the plan unanimously over objections from advocates, who said it bypassed the formal rate case where utility spending is publicly examined. A consultant’s review for those advocates estimated the later surcharge could add more than $50 a year to customer bills, on top of future rate increases.

Why it matters

The plan keeps gas bills flat now but lets National Grid seek recovery of $1.7 billion later, so today’s relief may become tomorrow’s bill.

Last Monday's email for New York, NY

Sent Nov 16. It carried:

Get next Monday's: one short email a week. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

1.9M
Downstate gas customers covered
National Grid serves New York City and Long Island through its downstate gas utilities.
$1.7B
Capital investments during freeze
National Grid estimates it will seek to recover this spending after the freeze.
$50+
Estimated annual surcharge after freeze
A Synapse review cited by advocates found the surcharge could add more than $50 a year to bills.
2.5%
Surcharge cap as share of operating revenue
The proposal caps the post-freeze surcharge at 2.5% of operating revenue.
1 year
Length of rate freeze
The freeze is set to run through March 2028.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

People Involved

Organizations Involved

Timeline

2026 November 2026

2 events Latest: Today
  1. Public Service Commission approves National Grid rate freeze

    Today Regulatory

    Commissioners unanimously backed the yearlong freeze over objections from advocates.

  2. National Grid proposes yearlong rate freeze for downstate gas utilities

    Filing

    The utility seeks to keep rates level and recover later about $1.7 billion in capital spending.

Scenarios

1

Surcharge hits National Grid bills after freeze ends

Likely Resolves by Q2 2028

Discussed by: Synapse Energy Economics review cited by Earthjustice; utility advocates

National Grid’s filings identify about $1.7 billion in freeze-period capital spending to recover later, and the Synapse review for advocates estimates a surcharge above $50 a year. If the PSC approves recovery after the freeze, customers would see those costs on bills beginning in 2028 or later.

2

PSC rejects recovery, National Grid absorbs freeze-period costs

Unlikely Resolves by End of 2028

Discussed by: Consumer advocates including Earthjustice and Alliance for a Green Economy

Consumer groups argued the plan was a rate hike in disguise and urged the PSC to reject it. If the commission later denies recovery or orders National Grid to absorb the spending, the freeze would become a genuine cost shift away from customers.

3

Advocates sue to overturn approval

Possible Resolves by Q2 2027

Discussed by: Earthjustice and Alliance for a Green Economy have signaled opposition; no lawsuit is reported in the cited record

Earthjustice and AGREE called the approval unlawful in comments and said the public was deprived of the normal rate case process. A state-court challenge could pause or overturn the PSC’s order, though utilities often prevail in ratemaking appeals.

Historical Context

2 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

1996-2001

California electricity rate freeze (1996-2001)

California deregulated its electricity market in 1996 and froze retail rates while wholesale prices were expected to fall. In 2000, wholesale prices spiked; utilities bought power at high prices and sold it at capped rates, accumulating billions in debt.

Then

PG&E filed for bankruptcy in 2001 and the state stepped in to buy power.

Now

The crisis discredited California’s deregulation design and showed how a rate freeze can shift costs into a later political and financial reckoning.

Why this matters now

National Grid’s plan keeps retail gas rates level now while deferring about $1.7 billion in capital costs, a smaller but similar timing trade-off.

2021-2022

UK energy price cap and supplier failures (2021-2022)

Ofgem’s household energy price cap limited how much suppliers could charge while wholesale gas prices rose sharply in 2021. More than 20 suppliers failed, and their customers were moved to other companies.

Then

The costs of failed suppliers were spread across remaining customers through a levy.

Now

The episode showed that price caps can protect customers in the short term while creating later costs or market instability.

Why this matters now

New York’s rate freeze is not a price cap, but it similarly postpones cost recovery rather than eliminating the underlying spending.

Sources

(2)