Rust v. Sullivan (1991)
The Supreme Court upheld a rule barring federally funded family planning clinics from discussing abortion with patients. The court held that when the government funds a program, it can define the program's scope, even if that limits what funded speakers may say.
The rule took effect and clinics restructured or declined federal funds.
Rust became the anchor for the government's argument that funding conditions are not viewpoint discrimination. Later cases narrowed it, holding that the government cannot impose conditions outside the funded program itself.
The administration's core defense rests on this line of reasoning: paying for research is a subsidy, and subsidies can carry limits. The 9th Circuit distinguished it, holding that once a competitive grant program exists, the government cannot pick winners by viewpoint.
