Pull to refresh
Logo
Chicago City Council approves outside review of city finances after chief financial officer resigns

Chicago City Council approves outside review of city finances after chief financial officer resigns

Money Moves Chicago, IL local

The 45-5 vote follows Ashlee Gabrysch's resignation and a budget fight with Mayor Brandon Johnson.

Overview

Updated 3 hours ago

Chicago's chief financial officer quit after three months, saying she could not keep making complete and accurate statements about the city's finances without compromising her integrity. Five days later, the City Council voted 45-5 to hire outside firms to review those statements.

The review gives aldermen an independent check on Mayor Brandon Johnson's 2027 budget as they negotiate a spending plan due by the end of the year. It also turns a personnel dispute into a test of whether investors and rating agencies can trust the city's fiscal numbers.

Why it matters

Chicago aldermen are hiring outside reviewers to check the mayor's budget math as the city passes a 2027 budget without a permanent chief financial officer.

Last Monday's email for Chicago, IL

Sent Nov 16. It carried:

Get next Monday's: one short email a week. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

45-5
City Council vote approving outside review
Aldermen voted 45-5 on Nov. 18, 2026, to let the finance committee hire outside firms.
3
Chief financial officers in less than a year
Ashlee Gabrysch was the third person to hold the role in under a year.
$882M
Initial 2027 deficit forecast
Johnson's budget team projected the gap in September 2026.
$652M
Adjusted 2027 deficit
The gap shrank after the administration moved police settlement borrowing out of the deficit.
76%
Share of gap-filling proposals Johnson called structural
Gabrysch publicly disputed that characterization during budget hearings.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

People Involved

Organizations Involved

Timeline

2026 November 2026

9 events Latest: Today
Tap a bar to jump to that date
  1. Council approves outside review

    Today Legislation

    The City Council voted 45-5 to let its finance committee hire outside reviewers.

  2. Mayor denies inaccurate data

    Statement

    Johnson said no one directed the chief financial officer to present inaccurate financial data.

  3. Chief financial officer resigns

    Personnel

    Ashlee Gabrysch quit after three months, citing integrity and professional obligations.

  4. Chief financial officer sets testimony terms

    Statement

    Gabrysch told aides her budget testimony terms were 'not open for revision.'

  5. Budget gap adjusted

    Budget

    The projected gap fell to $652 million after police settlement borrowing.

  6. Deficit forecast released

    Budget

    Johnson's budget team projected a $882 million 2027 gap.

  7. Budget director resigns

    Personnel

    Annette Guzman resigned; Jonathan Ernst became acting budget director.

  8. Acting chief financial officer exits

    Personnel

    Steven Mahr, serving as acting chief financial officer, left in July.

  9. First chief financial officer resigns

    Personnel

    Jill Jaworski, Johnson's first chief financial officer, left at the start of the year.

Scenarios

1

Review finds no material misstatements and budget passes

Possible Resolves by End of 2026

Discussed by: Johnson administration and acting chief financial officer Michael Belsky

The administration has called the dispute a matter of interpretation and says it welcomes an independent audit. If outside reviewers find the budget statements accurate, the review may defuse the fight and let Johnson and aldermen finish the 2027 budget by Dec. 31.

2

Review finds budget misstatements, council blocks Johnson plan

Possible Resolves by Q1 2027

Discussed by: Ald. Pat Dowell and other aldermen who opposed the budget

Dowell and other aldermen say they need the 'unvarnished truth' about the city's finances. If reviewers find that budget materials omitted material facts or overstated structural fixes, the council could reject main Johnson proposals, including the corporate head tax and lease tax increase.

3

Budget deadline passes without a deal

Unlikely Resolves by Jan 1, 2027

Discussed by: City Council and mayor's office warnings

The council must pass a 2027 budget by the end of the year or risk what the article calls an unprecedented government shutdown. If the review and budget fight stall negotiations, the city could enter 2027 without a spending plan.

Historical Context

2 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

1975

New York City fiscal crisis (1975)

New York City neared default as banks refused to roll over its debt. The state created the Municipal Assistance Corporation and an Emergency Financial Control Board to oversee city finances.

Then

The city imposed layoffs and wage freezes and adopted austere budgets.

Now

The control board shaped New York's budget for decades and became a model for state fiscal oversight.

Why this matters now

Chicago's fight is not a default crisis, but it shows how investor confidence and outside oversight can shift power over a city budget.

2013

Detroit bankruptcy (2013)

Detroit filed for Chapter 9 municipal bankruptcy after years of population loss and fiscal stress. The state had appointed an emergency manager to run the city.

Then

The bankruptcy restructured billions in debt and cut pensions and services.

Now

Detroit emerged with a smaller government and state oversight of its finances.

Why this matters now

The parallel is about credibility: when officials disagree over the numbers, outside reviewers and creditors can end up setting the terms.

Sources

(2)