Pull to refresh
Logo
FCC overrides California's landline rules to let AT&T retire copper

FCC overrides California's landline rules to let AT&T retire copper

Rule Changes

A 2-1 Federal Communications Commission order clears AT&T to drop basic phone service for about 199,000 California customers starting in June 2027.

Overview

Updated 2 hours ago

California requires phone companies to sell basic service to anyone in their territory. On November 20, the Federal Communications Commission told the state it cannot enforce that rule against AT&T, clearing the company to shut off copper landlines for about 199,000 customers starting June 1, 2027.

The dispute is over what counts as a phone line. AT&T wants to move those customers to AT&T Phone-Advanced, which runs on wireless and fiber. California says the company has not shown it meets state standards for 911 access, relay service, and low-income discounts.

Why it matters

About 199,000 California phone customers, many in rural and high-fire-risk areas, could lose wired service in 2027.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

184,000
Residential customers AT&T plans to disconnect
AT&T's FCC applications cover 360 wire centers across California.
15,000
Business customers AT&T plans to disconnect
Combined with residential lines, about 199,000 accounts are affected.
3%
Share of AT&T's California households still on copper
AT&T says that share keeps shrinking.
$1B
AT&T's estimated annual cost to maintain California copper
The company cites upkeep costs as a reason to retire the network.
360
Wire centers covered by AT&T's applications
Each wire center serves a geographic slice of the state's copper network.
2-1
FCC vote adopting the preemption order
The commission adopted the order November 13 and announced it November 20.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

People Involved

Organizations Involved

Timeline

May 2026 June 2027

6 events Latest: Yesterday
Tap a bar to jump to that date
  1. AT&T's planned copper cutoff

    Upcoming Planned

    AT&T says it will stop providing copper service to affected customers on this date.

  2. FCC announces California preemption

    Latest Regulatory

    The FCC says California cannot enforce carrier-of-last-resort rules in ways that stop AT&T's plan.

  3. FCC adopts preemption order, 2-1

    Regulatory

    The commission votes to preempt California requirements that block AT&T's copper retirement.

Scenarios

1

A court blocks the FCC's preemption before the 2027 cutoff

Possible Resolves by Jun 1, 2027

Discussed by: California officials and the CPUC, which has already sued the FCC over its preemption authority

California has challenged the FCC's authority in court and could appeal this order. If a federal court stays or vacates it, AT&T's June 2027 discontinuance would pause while the state's carrier-of-last-resort rules apply again.

2

AT&T shuts off copper on schedule in June 2027

Likely Resolves by End of 2027

Discussed by: AT&T, which says no customer will be left without voice or 911 service

If the order survives legal challenge, AT&T discontinues copper at the 360 wire centers and moves customers to AT&T Phone-Advanced. The company says it will work with customers through the switch.

3

CPUC rewrites its rules to accept the wireless replacement

Possible Resolves by Jun 1, 2027

Discussed by: The CPUC, which has an open proceeding on modernizing carrier-of-last-resort rules

The CPUC could revise its rules to treat AT&T Phone-Advanced as an acceptable replacement, ending the standoff. Commissioner Anna Gomez said the state should have been allowed to finish that work.

Historical Context

3 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

1990s

California's carrier-of-last-resort framework (1990s)

California designated certain phone companies as carriers of last resort, requiring them to offer service to any potential customer in their territory. The rules were written for an era when one company owned the local phone network.

Then

The framework kept basic phone service available across wide, sometimes costly-to-serve areas.

Now

AT&T says only about 3% of the California households it serves still use copper.

Why this matters now

The FCC order rests on the argument that these monopoly-era duties now block a transition the federal government has approved.

2005

Brand X and federal preemption of state telecom rules (2005)

The Supreme Court upheld the FCC's power to classify cable broadband as an information service rather than a regulated phone service. That classification displaced state common-carrier rules for cable internet.

Then

Cable broadband grew without state rate regulation.

Now

The decision established that the FCC's technical classifications can override state telecom rules.

Why this matters now

California's fight turns on the same question: whether a federal agency can decide what counts as a regulated phone service and displace a state's rules.

1996

The Telecommunications Act of 1996

Congress rewrote communications law to open local phone markets to competition, replacing the monopoly-era framework. It created the legal categories of telecommunications service and information service.

Then

Competitive carriers entered local phone markets.

Now

The categories still decide which services face common-carrier rules.

Why this matters now

The copper-retirement fight is a dispute over how those 1996 categories apply to a wireless and fiber replacement.

Sources

(5)