Pull to refresh
Logo
Peppermint Hippo takes over the former Hustler Club in Hell's Kitchen

Peppermint Hippo takes over the former Hustler Club in Hell's Kitchen

Money Moves New York, NY local

A new operator, a 20-year lease and a temporary liquor license keep adult entertainment at 641 West 51st Street

Overview

Updated 1 hour ago

Larry Flynt's Hustler Club ran at 641 West 51st Street for more than 20 years. On Oct. 5, New York's liquor authority granted a temporary license to a new operator, and the Hustler name could no longer be used at that address.

The replacement is Peppermint Hippo, a chain of seven clubs run by Alan Chang, who signed a 20-year lease with the building's owners. The temporary license runs through April 2027, when the state decides whether to make it annual.

Why it matters

The block keeps its adult club. What changed is the operator, the lease and the liquor license behind it.

Last Monday's email for New York, NY

Sent Nov 16. It carried:

Get next Monday's: one short email a week. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

20 years
Hustler Club's run at the address
The club operated at 641 West 51st Street from 2004 until the license changed hands in October 2026.
7
Peppermint Hippo clubs nationwide
The company also operates three Las Toxicas venues, according to its owner.
$1.16M
Wrongful-death verdict against the North Little Rock club
A man ejected from that club in 2021 was killed by a car; the verdict is under appeal.
2 a.m.
Rooftop bar closing time
The club agreed to the limit after Community Board 4 recommended against the license without it.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

People Involved

Organizations Involved

Timeline

2004 November 2026

8 events Latest: Yesterday
Tap a bar to jump to that date
  1. Gothamist notes the Hustler Club's replacement

    Latest Report

    The outlet's morning roundup reported the old Hustler Club had been replaced by a Peppermint Hippo.

  2. State grants a temporary liquor license

    Licensing

    The State Liquor Authority approved a temporary license, ending the Hustler club's ability to operate under its own.

  3. Board 4 sets a condition on the license

    Licensing

    The board recommended against the temporary license unless the rooftop bar closed at 2 a.m.

  4. Arkansas revokes the North Little Rock license

    Licensing

    The state alcohol board revoked the club's liquor license, citing violations dating to the 2021 death.

  5. Board 4 rejects a nearby adult-entertainment bid

    Zoning

    The board voted against Musica's request to add adult entertainment, citing clustering and proximity to the Hustler Club.

  6. First Peppermint Hippo opens

    Business

    Alan Chang opens his first club under the Peppermint Hippo name.

  7. Hustler Club opens on West 51st Street

    Opening

    Larry Flynt's Hustler Club begins operating at 641 West 51st Street, near the West Side Highway.

Scenarios

1

State grants Peppermint Hippo a full annual liquor license

Likely Resolves by Apr 30, 2027

Discussed by: amNewYork, which reported the temporary license runs through April 2027

The temporary license issued Oct. 5 expires in April. A full annual license would follow the same review, and the club has already accepted the condition Board 4 asked for: a 2 a.m. rooftop bar closing time. The site's existing adult-entertainment use works in the applicant's favor, since the location is already licensed for that purpose.

2

Temporary license lapses and the club goes dark

Unlikely Resolves by Apr 30, 2027

Discussed by: No public prediction; included because the license is explicitly temporary

The license granted in October is valid only through April. If the authority declines to renew or the applicant withdraws, the club would have to stop serving alcohol at the address. Nothing in the public record suggests this is under way, and the operator has a 20-year lease.

3

Arkansas appeals court upholds the wrongful-death verdict

Possible Resolves by Q2 2027

Discussed by: amNewYork, which reported the appeal is pending with no ruling

A jury awarded $1.16 million against the North Little Rock Peppermint Hippo over the 2021 death, finding the club served the man too much alcohol. The club appealed to the Arkansas Court of Appeals, which has not ruled. A decision against the chain would not affect the New York license, but it would settle a liability question hanging over the company as it expands.

Historical Context

3 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

2004

Hustler Club opens at 641 West 51st Street (2004)

Larry Flynt's Hustler Club took the far-west-side address and held it for more than two decades, with the building's owners licensing the name and running the club themselves. The stretch near the West Side Highway had kept adult entertainment as a visible use while the rest of Hell's Kitchen built up around it.

Then

The club became a fixture on a block that otherwise saw industrial and nightlife uses turn over.

Now

The address carried an adult-entertainment liquor license continuously, which is what made a same-use transfer possible in 2026.

Why this matters now

Alan Chang said the existing adult use made licensing easier than a new location would have been. The 2026 switch is a change of operator at a site already zoned and licensed for the purpose.

June 2021 - March 2023

The Q opens and closes in Hell's Kitchen (2021-2023)

A four-story LGBTQ nightclub opened on Eighth Avenue near 48th Street in June 2021, after pandemic delays, with backing from celebrity investors including Billy Porter and Zachary Quinto. In June 2022 one of its three founding owners sued the other two. The club closed in March 2023.

Then

A large, heavily publicized nightlife venue shut less than two years after opening.

Now

The space changed hands rather than changing use, a pattern repeated across the neighborhood's commercial corridors.

Why this matters now

Hell's Kitchen nightlife venues turn over quickly. The Hustler-to-Peppermint-Hippo switch is the opposite case: the use stayed, only the operator changed.

December 2025

Community Board 4 rejects Musica's adult-entertainment bid (2025)

The Musica nightclub at West 50th Street and 12th Avenue sought a zoning variance to add adult entertainment. Board 4 voted against it in December, citing concerns about clustering and proximity to the Hustler Club. The club later withdrew the proposal.

Then

The venue dropped its plan rather than fight the board.

Now

The episode showed how the city's 500-foot separation rule and board opposition constrain new adult venues in the area.

Why this matters now

Peppermint Hippo avoided that fight entirely by taking over a site that was already an adult club, rather than asking to convert a new one.

Sources

(3)