Pull to refresh
Logo
Second phase of Hunts Point's Spofford jail redevelopment opens

Second phase of Hunts Point's Spofford jail redevelopment opens

Built World New York, NY local

The $297 million Peninsula phase adds 359 income-restricted apartments to the former juvenile detention site, with a third phase still to come

Overview

Updated 1 hour ago

Spofford Juvenile Detention Center held children awaiting trial in Hunts Point for more than 50 years. The city closed it in 2011 after residents spent years documenting abuse and violence inside. On Nov. 12, the second phase of the complex replacing it opened with 359 income-restricted apartments.

The $297 million phase is the largest piece yet of a plan to put about 740 affordable homes, a city-owned grocery store and community space on the old jail site. Two buildings are finished. A third phase, carrying roughly 200 more units, is not scheduled to close until December 2027.

Why it matters

Hunts Point is replacing a jail with 740 subsidized homes. Whether the last 200 get built is a test of New York's affordable housing promises.

Last Monday's email for New York, NY

Sent Nov 16. It carried:

Get next Monday's: one short email a week. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

359
Apartments in Phase Two
Studios through four-bedroom units across the two Spofford Avenue buildings.
740
Total homes planned
Full three-phase build-out, all income-restricted.
$297M
Phase Two cost
Combined public and private financing for the second phase.
15%
Units for formerly homeless households
54 apartments set aside in Phase Two.
183
Phase One apartments
Completed in 2022 and already occupied.
60%
Area median income ceiling
Upper income limit for most units; 73 percent are at or below this line.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

People Involved

Organizations Involved

Timeline

1950s December 2027

7 events Latest: Today
Tap a bar to jump to that date
  1. Third phase targeted to reach financial close

    Upcoming Development

    The final phase would add roughly 200 units and a manufacturing building.

  2. City-owned grocery store targeted to open

    Upcoming Development

    A 15,000-square-foot storefront is reserved; the target was set at Thanksgiving 2027.

  3. Completion of Phase Two reported

    Today Media

    New York YIMBY reports construction finished on the two Spofford Avenue towers.

  4. Phase Two ribbon cutting at 1221 and 1225 Spofford Avenue

    Construction

    Two 14-story buildings add 359 apartments, a 45,000-square-foot plaza and an early childhood center.

  5. Peninsula Phase One opens with 183 affordable units

    Construction

    The first building on the former jail site begins leasing to income-restricted households.

  6. City closes Spofford after years of advocacy

    Policy

    Residents had documented abuse, violence and conditions at the jail. The site went vacant.

  7. Spofford Juvenile Detention Center operates in Hunts Point

    History

    For more than 50 years the city-run facility held children 15 and under awaiting trial or placement.

Scenarios

1

Third phase closes on schedule, completing 740 units by 2028

Possible Resolves by Q1 2028

Discussed by: The development team and former Council member Rafael Salamanca Jr., who both cite a December 2027 closing target

Gilbane, Hudson and MHANY secure the remaining financing for the final phase and start construction on the last residential building and the manufacturing building. Lease-up would follow within about two years, pushing the site to roughly 740 affordable homes.

2

Third phase slips as construction costs and financing stay tight

Possible Resolves by End of 2028

Discussed by: No named forecaster yet; the risk is implied by the phase's dependence on public subsidy and a 2027 target that is more than a year out

The final phase misses its December 2027 closing target. Rising construction and borrowing costs, or a delay in city capital commitments, push groundbreaking into 2029 or later, leaving the site with 542 completed units and an undeveloped parcel.

3

City-owned grocery store opens by Thanksgiving 2027

Uncertain Resolves by Nov 25, 2027

Discussed by: City officials, who have described the store as among the first municipal grocery stores

An operator opens a grocery in the 15,000-square-foot commercial space facing the new plaza, meeting the target set at the Phase Two opening. The store would be the first such city-owned grocery to open in New York.

Historical Context

2 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

1950s-2011

Spofford Juvenile Detention Center closes (2011)

The Spofford facility held children 15 and under awaiting trial or transfer for more than half a century. Residents and advocates spent years documenting abuse, violence and conditions inside before the city shut it down in 2011, leaving a large site vacant in Hunts Point.

Then

The building sat unused while the city searched for a redevelopment plan.

Now

The closure became the starting point for a multi-phase, mixed-use replacement that community groups helped design.

Why this matters now

The Peninsula's phases are the direct result of the closure. Each new building is measured against what the jail represented to the neighborhood.

2022

Peninsula Phase One opens (2022)

The first building delivered 183 income-restricted apartments on the site, roughly a quarter of the eventual 740-unit total. It established the financing structure and leasing process through NYC Housing Connect that later phases depend on.

Then

Phase One leased up and proved the site could work as housing.

Now

It set the pattern that Phase Two followed and that Phase Three must complete.

Why this matters now

Phase Two quadruples the number of homes delivered so far and is the test of whether the full 740-unit promise holds.

Sources

(3)