Sony Music vs. Quad9, Germany (2021-2023)
A German court ordered Quad9 to block content Sony Music said was pirated. Quad9 tried geo-blocking, restricting access by location, but a Sony employee used a VPN to reach the blocked content from Germany anyway. The court agreed with Sony that Quad9 was noncompliant and fined it for contempt.
Quad9 paid contempt fines before the matter ultimately resolved in its favor.
Quad9 concluded location-based blocking is unreliable and says it will not attempt it again.
Quad9 cites the German failure as the reason it refuses to try geo-blocking in France, calling it a 'hack' that cannot be validated and that a determined user can bypass.
