Pull to refresh
Logo
San Francisco board approves pause on new data centers

San Francisco board approves pause on new data centers

Rule Changes San Francisco, CA local

Supervisors voted unanimously Nov. 17 to extend the pause 10 months and 15 days, past its Nov. 30 expiration

Overview

Updated 3 days ago

San Francisco supervisors voted unanimously Nov. 17 to extend the city's ban on new data centers 10 months and 15 days past its Nov. 30 expiration, carrying the pause into next fall. The original 45-day order, signed by Mayor Daniel Lurie on Oct. 16, had two weeks left to run. The vote came days before Anthropic's stock market debut.

A city report released Nov. 10 found San Francisco is close to its ceiling on electricity transmission: peak demand was about 800 megawatts in 2025 against a 1,000-megawatt limit. One 50-megawatt data center could draw as much power as 25,000 homes. A planned expansion of the NOVVA facility on Paul Avenue, from 9 to 36 megawatts, is on hold.

Why it matters

Other cities are watching whether San Francisco's pause becomes permanent rules for AI data centers, or a template for blocking them.

Last Monday's email for San Francisco, CA

Sent Nov 16. It carried:

Get next Monday's: one short email a week. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

10.5 months
Extension length
Supervisors voted Nov. 17 to extend the pause 10 months and 15 days past its Nov. 30 expiration, into fall 2027.
50 MW
Power demand example
A 50-megawatt data center could use as much electricity as 25,000 homes, the city report says.
1,000 MW
Grid ceiling
The city's maximum transmission capacity. Peak demand was about 800 megawatts in 2025 and has been rising since, the Planning Department reported.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

People Involved

Organizations Involved

Timeline

2001 November 2026

16 events Latest: 4 days ago Showing 8 of 16
Tap a bar to jump to that date
  1. Board extends data center moratorium 10 months and 15 days

    Latest Policy

    Supervisors voted unanimously to extend the interim moratorium 10 months and 15 days past its Nov. 30 expiration. Supervisor Connie Chan was absent.

  2. San Joaquin County extends hyperscale data center moratorium

    Policy

    The county Board of Supervisors extended its ban on hyperscale data centers in unincorporated areas for 10 months and 15 days while staff study environmental and economic effects and seek community input.

  3. Land use committee recommends extension

    Policy

    The Land Use and Transportation Committee recommended the 10.5-month extension, sending it to the full board for the Nov. 17 vote.

  4. Building trades council opposes a permanent ban

    Statement

    Rudy Gonzalez, head of the Building and Construction Trades Council, wrote to supervisors arguing developers should have a path to approval if they meet enforceable environmental and labor standards and pay for the infrastructure they need.

  5. Planning report warns of grid strain

    Report

    The Planning Department's report said a 50-megawatt data center could use as much electricity as 25,000 homes and that the city is nearing its transmission capacity. It did not recommend whether to extend the moratorium.

  6. Oakland extends data center moratorium

    Policy

    Oakland City Council voted unanimously to extend its data center moratorium for 10 months and 15 days, through Oct. 5, 2027.

  7. Hearing scheduled on Planning Department findings

    Hearing

    The ordinance requires the Planning Department to report to the clerk of the board within 25 days of Oct. 16 and a hearing within 35 days.

  8. Walton proposes 10.5-month extension

    Policy

    Supervisor Shamann Walton introduced an ordinance (Board File 261175) to extend the interim moratorium for 10 months and 15 days beyond its Nov. 30 expiration.

  9. Fairfield vice mayor announces plan to propose moratorium

    Policy

    Pam Bertani said she would make a motion for a data center moratorium at the Oct. 20 council meeting. No outcome from that meeting was reported in the sources reviewed.

  10. Board unanimously approves 45-day moratorium

    Policy

    San Francisco Board of Supervisors voted unanimously to approve the moratorium. Mayor Daniel Lurie signed it on Oct. 16.

  11. Committee advances Walton's proposal

    Policy

    Land Use and Transportation Committee advanced the moratorium to the full board after a hearing with more than a dozen supporters.

  12. LA County halts new data centers on unincorporated land

    Policy

    LA County planning director ordered an immediate halt to new data center development on unincorporated land.

  13. Richmond approves moratorium; Walton introduces SF ordinance

    Policy

    Richmond City Council approved a similar moratorium. Walton introduced his 45-day pause in San Francisco with three co-sponsors.

  14. Gilroy enacts 45-day data center moratorium

    Policy

    Gilroy City Council unanimously enacted an immediate 45-day pause on new data center approvals.

  15. Developer asks city about permits for AI data center at former Bloomingdale's

    Development

    A construction consultant for Maryland-based KG Growth Partners asked the Department of Building Inspection what permits an AI data center would need at 845 Market St., about 350,000 square feet Bloomingdale's had occupied. No permit application had been filed as of Oct. 16.

  16. SF zoning framework for data centers designed

    Policy

    San Francisco's current zoning rules for data centers were written, predating the AI era.

Scenarios

1

Mayor signs data center moratorium into law

Deadline passed (Oct 20, 2026)

Discussed by: The San Francisco Standard, city political observers

The 45-day moratorium takes effect without a veto from Mayor Daniel Lurie, triggering the pause on new data center approvals and starting the Planning Department's study. The board could then vote to extend it to 22 months while long-term rules are developed.

2

Moratorium extended to 22 months after planning study

Possible Resolves by Dec 15, 2026

Discussed by: The San Francisco Standard, Planning Department

After the initial 45-day period, the board votes to extend the moratorium to 22 months while the Planning Department develops long-term data center zoning rules. This would give the city time to craft new standards for energy, water, and community impacts.

3

Moratorium expires after 45 days without long-term rules

Possible Resolves by Dec 15, 2026

Discussed by: Data center industry observers

The moratorium runs its 45-day course without extension. The Planning Department's study continues, but new data center applications resume under the existing 2001 zoning rules. The article notes it's unclear whether city leaders would entertain an extension.

4

San Francisco makes data center moratorium permanent

Possible Resolves by Jan 31, 2027

Discussed by: Mission Local, candidates for District 10

Walton has said he hopes the moratorium grows into a permanent ban. Support for stronger controls, and possibly an outright ban, is rising among the candidates running to succeed him. If the Planning Department's study finds data centers harm nearby residents, the board could adopt lasting restrictions or controls.

5

Board extends the data center moratorium past Nov. 30

Possible Resolves by Nov 30, 2026

Discussed by: Mission Local, Data Center Feed

State law lets the board extend an interim ordinance for up to 22 months if it finds data centers pose a significant environmental impact. Supervisors voted unanimously Nov. 17 for a 10-month-and-15-day extension, keeping approvals frozen while permanent zoning rules are written.

6

AI exhibit at the former Bloomingdale's gets permits after the pause

Uncertain Resolves by Q2 2027

Discussed by: KG Growth Partners, San Francisco Chronicle reporting

KG Growth Partners has described the 845 Market St. concept as a community-facing AI exhibit rather than a server hall. It still needs a buyer to win the bid and city permits, and the moratorium bars approvals until it lifts.

7

San Francisco adopts permanent data center rules before the pause ends

Possible Resolves by Q3 2027

Discussed by: San Francisco Planning Department, Board of Supervisors

Planners use the extension to draft zoning changes covering power use, backup generator emissions and neighborhood impacts, and send them to supervisors before the extended moratorium runs out.

Historical Context

2 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

2001

San Francisco's 2001 data center zoning rules

San Francisco designed its zoning framework for data centers in 2001, when computing infrastructure was far less resource-intensive. The rules don't account for the energy, water, and environmental demands of modern AI data centers.

Then

The rules governed data center development for 25 years.

Now

The framework is now seen as outdated for AI-era infrastructure.

Why this matters now

Walton cited the 2001 rules as the reason for the moratorium: 'We should not be approving this new generation of industrial infrastructure under rules that were written 25 years ago.'

September 2026

California's September 2026 data center moratorium wave

Gilroy (Sept 14), Richmond (Sept 15), and Oakley enacted moratoriums on new data center approvals. Oakland and Los Angeles County followed with their own pauses.

Then

A regional pause on data center development across the Bay Area and beyond.

Now

Cities are developing long-term zoning rules for AI infrastructure.

Why this matters now

San Francisco's moratorium is part of this coordinated regional response to the rapid growth of AI data centers.

Sources

(25)