Lincoln Chafee loses in Rhode Island (2006)
Rhode Island Republican Lincoln Chafee, a moderate in a heavily Democratic state, lost his Senate seat to Democrat Sheldon Whitehouse. President George W. Bush's low approval and the Iraq war weighed on Chafee throughout the race.
Democrats picked up the seat and won control of the Senate.
Chafee's defeat became a template for how national unpopularity can sink a moderate New England Republican.
Collins faced the same dynamic: a moderate Republican in a blue state, tied to an unpopular president and rising costs.
