How U.S. Catholic archdioceses are paying for decades of clergy abuse
Money Moves
New York’s $300 million proposal and New Orleans’ court-approved deal mark the latest phase in a two‑decade reckoning over who pays—and what survivors get—in the Catholic abuse crisis.
New York’s $300 million proposal and New Orleans’ court-approved deal mark the latest phase in a two‑decade reckoning over who pays—and what survivors get—in the Catholic abuse crisis.
The New York Archdiocese's $300 million settlement proposal faces a new obstacle: in a January 31, 2026 court filing, Cardinal Timothy Dolan accused insurer Chubb of secretly operating a website called the "Church Accountability Project" to encourage abuse survivors to sue the archdiocese while simultaneously denying insurance coverage for those claims. The archdiocese says Chubb presented the site as an independent victims' rights initiative but used it to weaken the church's negotiating position. Retired Judge Daniel Buckley has been appointed to mediate talks with roughly 1,300 claimants, but the escalating Chubb dispute threatens to derail a non-bankruptcy settlement path.
Meanwhile, the New Orleans Archdiocese secured court approval of its $230 million settlement in early December 2025, with insurer Travelers agreeing in principle to contribute an additional $75 million, bringing the total to $305 million. Together, these two cases—one pursuing mediation outside bankruptcy, the other emerging from Chapter 11—illustrate the diverging strategies Catholic dioceses are using to resolve decades of abuse claims while battling insurers over who bears the financial burden.
Click a figure to generate their perspective on this story
Debate Arena
Two rounds, two personas, one winner. You set the crossfire.
Choose Your Battle
Watch two AI personas debate this story using real evidence
Make predictions and set the crossfire to earn XP and cred
Select Your Champions
Choose one persona for each side of the debate
DEBATE TOPIC
SIDE A (PRO)
Select debater for this side:
✓
SIDE B (CON)
Select debater for this side:
✓
Choose personas with different perspectives for a more dynamic debate
VS
Get ready to make your prediction...
Round of
Claim
Evidence
Stakes
Crossfire Answer
Closing Statement
Claim
Evidence
Stakes
Crossfire Answer
Closing Statement
Your Crossfire Question
Generating arguments...
Who's Got This Round?
Make your prediction before the referee scores
Correct predictions earn +20 XP
Evidence
40%
Logic
30%
Detail
20%
Style
10%
Round Results
Your Pick!
+20 XP
Your Pick
Not this time
Evidence (40%)
Logic (30%)
Detail (20%)
Style (10%)
Overall Score
/10
Your Pick!
+20 XP
Your Pick
Not this time
Evidence (40%)
Logic (30%)
Detail (20%)
Style (10%)
Overall Score
/10
Set the Crossfire
Pick the question both personas must answer in the final round
Crafting crossfire questions...
Choosing a question earns +10 XP crossfire bonus
🏆
Total XP Earned
Cred Change
Predictions
Debate Oracle! You called every round!
Sharp Instincts! You know your debaters!
The Coin Flip Strategist! Perfectly balanced!
The Contrarian! Bold predictions!
Inverse Genius! Try betting the opposite next time!
XP Breakdown
Base completion+20 XP
Rounds played ( rounds x 5 XP)
+ XP
Correct predictions ( correct x 20 XP)
+ XP
Crossfire bonus+10 XP
Accuracy
%
Prediction History
Round
You picked:
✓✗
Keep debating to level up your credibility and unlock achievements
Who Said What?
WHO SAID WHAT?
Can you match the quotes to the right people?
Rounds
People
Score:
Round /
streak
-- ?
Score:
Round /
streak
Next Up
Round
of
points
Correct
Best Streak
Time Bonus
People Involved
Timothy Cardinal Dolan
Archbishop of New York (Leading $300M settlement push while accusing Chubb of covert campaign to undermine archdiocese's legal position)
Daniel J. Buckley
Retired Los Angeles Superior Court judge and settlement mediator (Appointed mediator for New York’s abuse claims after administering Los Angeles’s $880M settlement)
Jeff Anderson
Attorney for abuse survivors (Represents roughly 300 New York claimants and hundreds more nationwide)
Meredith Grabill
U.S. Bankruptcy Judge for the Eastern District of Louisiana (Approved New Orleans Archdiocese’s $230M abuse settlement plan)
Gregory Aymond
Archbishop of New Orleans (Guiding archdiocese through bankruptcy settlement and impending leadership transition)
Organizations Involved
RO
Roman Catholic Archdiocese of New York
Catholic archdiocese
Status: Facing more than 1,300 abuse lawsuits; proposing $300M mediated settlement fund
The nation’s most prominent Catholic archdiocese is trying to settle a tidal wave of abuse claims without entering bankruptcy.
RO
Roman Catholic Archdiocese of New Orleans
Catholic archdiocese
Status: In Chapter 11; $230M abuse settlement approved with potential insurer add‑on
One of America’s oldest dioceses used bankruptcy to bundle hundreds of abuse claims into a single, court‑approved deal.
CH
Chubb Limited
Insurance company
Status: Accused of secretly operating abuse-advocacy website while denying coverage; coverage dispute intensifies amid mediation talks
The archdiocese’s longtime insurer is trying to convince courts it doesn’t have to help pay for systemic abuse.
Timeline
Archdiocese accuses Chubb of secretly running abuse-advocacy website
Legal
In a New York State Supreme Court filing, the Archdiocese of New York alleges that insurer Chubb secretly operated the "Church Accountability Project" website to encourage abuse survivors to sue the archdiocese while denying insurance coverage, calling it a covert effort to weaken the church's legal position.
New York Archdiocese proposes $300M fund and mediation
Settlement
The Archdiocese of New York announces plans to raise $300 million via asset sales, layoffs, and budget cuts to compensate about 1,300 abuse survivors. It agrees to mediated talks led by retired Judge Daniel Buckley, even as its feud with insurer Chubb over coverage continues.
Judge approves New Orleans Archdiocese’s $230M settlement
Legal
Bankruptcy Judge Meredith Grabill confirms a plan creating a $230 million trust for about 600 survivors, funded by the archdiocese and 150 affiliated entities. Insurer Travelers separately agrees in principle to add $75 million, pending court approval.
New Orleans survivors vote overwhelmingly for $230M plan
Legal
Roughly 99.6% of voting creditors, including nearly all abuse survivors, back a $230 million plan to resolve the New Orleans bankruptcy, clearing the way for a confirmation trial on fairness and feasibility.
Los Angeles Archdiocese agrees to $880M settlement
Settlement
The Los Angeles Archdiocese, already a symbol of the abuse crisis, agrees to pay $880 million to resolve 1,353 revived claims, the largest single settlement by a Catholic archdiocese. Retired Judge Daniel Buckley oversees the settlement program.
Rockville Centre diocese reaches $323M bankruptcy settlement
Settlement
A New York diocese serving Long Island Catholics agrees to a $323 million settlement with about 600 survivors, the largest diocesan bankruptcy deal to that point. The plan uses limited Chapter 11 filings by all parishes to secure releases and unlock insurer contributions.
Court lets Chubb’s coverage lawsuit against New York Archdiocese proceed
Legal
A New York appellate court allows Chubb’s declaratory judgment suit to move forward, in which the insurer argues the archdiocese expected or intended abuse and thus voided insurance coverage. The archdiocese denounces Chubb’s position as absurd and fear‑mongering.
New Orleans Archdiocese files Chapter 11 amid abuse fallout
Legal
The New Orleans Archdiocese seeks bankruptcy protection as abuse allegations and other financial pressures mount. Hundreds of survivors eventually file claims, and the case stretches more than five years.
New York’s Child Victims Act window opens, unleashing lawsuits
Law
A new law temporarily suspends civil time limits for child abuse claims, triggering at least 2,800 suits against Catholic entities statewide, including more than 700 against the New York Archdiocese alone.
New York launches Independent Reconciliation and Compensation Program
Compensation Program
Cardinal Dolan unveils a voluntary compensation program for survivors who had already reported abuse, run by mediator Kenneth Feinberg with no cap on total payouts. The archdiocese later reports paying more than $40 million to nearly 200 people.
Portland becomes first U.S. diocese to file bankruptcy over abuse
Legal
The Archdiocese of Portland in Oregon files for Chapter 11 protection to manage mounting abuse claims, signaling that bankruptcy can be used to corral diocesan liability into a single, court‑supervised settlement process.
Boston Archdiocese agrees to $85M deal, igniting national focus
Settlement
Boston’s archdiocese announces an $85 million settlement with more than 500 abuse survivors, financed largely through mortgaging and selling church property. The deal becomes a template and warning sign for other U.S. dioceses facing similar claims.
Scenarios
1
New York Archdiocese Reaches $300M Global Settlement, Avoids Bankruptcy
Discussed by: Reuters, AP, the Guardian, and Catholic outlets covering diocesan finance and abuse litigation
Under this path, Buckley’s mediation produces a deal in the $300 million range that most of the 1,300-plus survivors accept. The archdiocese finishes selling its former headquarters and other assets, locks in financing, and either squeezes a partial contribution from Chubb or eats more of the cost itself. Survivors get faster, if imperfect, compensation and some document disclosure commitments, while the archdiocese preserves control of its restructuring instead of handing it to a bankruptcy judge. The deal becomes a model for large dioceses hoping to settle outside Chapter 11.
2
Talks Collapse, New York Archdiocese Follows New Orleans Into Chapter 11
Discussed by: Legal analysts and survivor attorneys who note Chubb’s hard line and the scale of claims
If mediation stalls—because survivors demand substantially more money and transparency, insurers refuse to fund a deal, or appeals drag on—the archdiocese may find that Chapter 11 is the only way to corral 1,300+ lawsuits and bind insurers and parishes into a single plan. A bankruptcy filing would freeze trials, shift leverage to a creditors’ committee, and likely force broader disclosure of internal abuse files. It would echo New Orleans and Rockville Centre, but on an even higher‑profile stage, raising questions about parish closures and long‑term trust in church leadership.
3
Insurers Pushed Into Bigger, Reform‑Heavy Settlements Nationwide
Discussed by: Coverage of Rockville Centre, Los Angeles, New Orleans and New York in national and Catholic press
As more diocesan cases converge—Los Angeles’s $880 million deal, Rockville Centre’s $323 million plan, New Orleans’s $230–$305 million settlement, and New York’s proposed fund—judges and mediators could pressure insurers to contribute more in exchange for predictable, global peace. In return, survivor groups and attorneys might insist on stronger non‑monetary terms: mandatory disclosure of abusers’ files, independent audits of safeguarding programs, and limits on future confidentiality. The result would be larger, more uniform settlements where insurers, not just dioceses, shoulder a bigger share, and transparency—rather than quiet payouts—becomes the new price of closure.
Historical Context
Boston’s 2003 Settlement and the Modern Abuse Reckoning
2002–2003
What Happened
After the Boston Globe’s Spotlight investigation exposed widespread cover‑ups, the Archdiocese of Boston agreed in 2003 to pay $85 million to 552 abuse survivors. The settlement, financed partly by mortgaging and selling church property, marked the first large, public attempt by a major U.S. archdiocese to buy civil closure and triggered similar disclosures and lawsuits nationwide.
Outcome
Short Term
Boston’s deal ended many local cases but cemented the scandal as a national story and encouraged more survivors to sue.
Long Term
It established the idea that dioceses would have to move assets, negotiate en masse, and sometimes fight insurers to resolve systemic abuse.
Why It's Relevant Today
New York’s plan to sell prime real estate and pool payouts into a fixed fund closely echoes Boston’s early playbook, scaled up for a larger, later wave of claims.
Diocesan Bankruptcies as a Tool: Portland to Rockville Centre
2004–2024
What Happened
Beginning with Portland in 2004, dozens of U.S. dioceses and Catholic entities used Chapter 11 to halt trials and negotiate global abuse settlements under court supervision. Rockville Centre’s 2024 plan, at $323 million, became the largest diocesan bankruptcy settlement, crafted amid new Supreme Court limits on shielding non‑bankrupt affiliates and creative strategies to pull parishes into abbreviated bankruptcies.
Outcome
Short Term
Bankruptcy centralized claims, capped diocesan exposure, and often produced nine‑figure settlements with strict voting thresholds.
Long Term
It normalized Chapter 11 as a quasi‑standard path for dioceses overwhelmed by revival‑law suits, but also drew criticism for opacity and for limiting survivors’ day‑in‑court.
Why It's Relevant Today
New York’s effort to settle outside bankruptcy is being watched as a possible alternative to this model—or a prelude to joining it if mediation fails.
Los Angeles’s $880M Deal and the Era of Mega‑Settlements
2007–2024
What Happened
The Los Angeles Archdiocese first paid $660 million in 2007, then in 2024 agreed to another $880 million settlement for 1,353 revived claims under California’s extended statute of limitations. The program, administered with help from retired Judge Daniel Buckley, relied on reserves, loans, and contributions from religious orders and insurers to avoid bankruptcy while still delivering one of the largest abuse payouts in U.S. history.
Outcome
Short Term
The deal resolved nearly all remaining LA claims and pushed total payouts there above $1.5 billion.
Long Term
It showed that very large archdioceses can sometimes finance enormous settlements without Chapter 11, provided they mobilize assets and secure insurer participation.
Why It's Relevant Today
New York’s decision to bring in the same judge who managed Los Angeles’s settlement signals it is aiming for a similar, non‑bankruptcy mega‑deal—if it can overcome a more hostile lead insurer.
