United States v. Ballin (1892)
A tariff bill passed the House 138 to 112, and opponents argued no quorum existed because members in the chamber had not voted. The Supreme Court upheld the House's own rule for counting them, holding that each chamber judges whether a quorum is present and that the Constitution requires only that a majority be present.
The tariff stood and the House's authority over its own quorum determination went largely unchallenged.
Ballin became the baseline precedent on the Quorum Clause and is now cited by both sides in the proxy dispute.
The Fifth Circuit majority read Ballin as resting on physical presence, while critics say the decision deferred to the chamber's rules — the opposite conclusion.
