Overview
Maryland just became the latest battleground in a national fight to protect firefighters from cancer. Starting January 1, 2026, every Maryland county with a self-insured health plan must provide free cancer screenings to professional firefighters—no copays, no deductibles, no excuses. The law, named for former Delegate Jimmy Malone who died of brain cancer after decades in the fire service, targets ten cancer types that kill firefighters at dramatically higher rates than the general population.
This isn't just another healthcare mandate. Firefighters face a 9% higher cancer diagnosis rate and 14% higher cancer death rate than other Americans, with some cancers—like mesothelioma—hitting them at double the normal rate. In 2022, the World Health Organization's cancer agency finally upgraded firefighting to its highest hazard classification: Group 1, carcinogenic to humans, the same category as tobacco and asbestos. Now states are racing to answer a question with billions in workers' comp costs hanging in the balance: Should governments pay to find cancer early, or wait until firefighters file disability claims?
Key Indicators
People Involved
Organizations Involved
The WHO's cancer research arm that evaluates carcinogenic hazards to humans.
The union representing professional firefighters, driving legislative campaigns for cancer presumption and screening laws.
Maryland's legislature has progressively expanded firefighter cancer protections over seven years.
Timeline
-
Maryland Requires Cancer Screening Coverage for Firefighters
ImplementationJames Malone Act takes effect, requiring counties with self-insured plans to cover preventive cancer screenings at no cost.
-
Maryland Legislature Passes James Malone Act
LegislationCross-filed as HB 459 and SB 374, mandates free cancer screenings for firefighters in counties with self-insured plans.
-
Former Delegate Jimmy Malone Dies of Brain Cancer
PersonalCareer firefighter and former Maryland delegate dies at 67, three weeks before law bearing his name takes effect.
-
WHO Declares Firefighting Definitively Carcinogenic
ScientificIARC upgrades firefighting from possibly carcinogenic (Group 2B) to carcinogenic to humans (Group 1).
-
Maryland Passes Jesse McCullough's Cancer Protection Law
LegislationMaryland expands workers' compensation presumptions for firefighters with 10+ years of service who develop cancer.
-
Maryland Creates Cancer Screening Grant Program
PolicyLegislature establishes Professional and Volunteer Firefighter Innovative Cancer Screening Technologies Program with $100,000 annual funding.
Scenarios
Screening Mandates Spread to Most States
Discussed by: First Responder Center for Excellence, firefighter advocacy groups, and state legislators introducing similar bills
Maryland's model goes national as states shift from reactive workers' comp to proactive screening. Kansas already launched a $250,000 program for Wichita firefighters. Pennsylvania included firefighter screening in the governor's budget. New Jersey and Connecticut announced enhanced screening programs in 2025. Federal legislation (the FIRE Cancer Act) aims to guarantee multi-cancer early detection tests nationwide. If early data from Maryland and other programs shows cost savings through early detection versus late-stage treatment, resistant states face political pressure from firefighter unions and actuarial logic: paying for annual screenings beats six-figure cancer disability claims.
Insurance Industry Backlash Stalls Expansion
Discussed by: Pennsylvania's post-2011 experience, insurance industry analysis, workers' compensation cost studies
The insurance market revolts like it did in Pennsylvania, where most carriers dropped firefighter workers' comp coverage after the state's 2011 cancer presumption law. Counties and municipalities face soaring premiums or coverage gaps, especially in states with large volunteer fire departments. Vermont's data shows two cancer claims totaling $4.6 million—nearly half of all major claims. If Maryland counties report major cost overruns by 2028 when the mandated study is due, the backlash could freeze similar legislation nationwide and trigger amendments weakening the mandate.
Multi-Cancer Blood Tests Become Standard
Discussed by: Clinical trials at Vincere Cancer Center, GRAIL (Galleri test manufacturer), Maryland's grant program framework
Maryland's law explicitly allows counties to use grants for multi-cancer early detection blood tests instead of traditional screenings. These MCED tests detect 50+ cancer types from a single blood draw—far more efficient than separate screenings for bladder, prostate, skin, and testicular cancers. If the LEVANTIS-0065 clinical study of firefighters shows MCED tests outperform conventional screening, Maryland counties shift grant money toward blood tests. Within five years, a single annual blood draw replaces the patchwork of imaging, biopsies, and specialist visits, dramatically cutting costs and boosting compliance.
Presumptive Laws Expand Beyond Firefighters
Discussed by: Legislative researchers, workers' compensation policy analysts, occupational health advocates
Firefighters were the test case. Now other high-risk professions demand the same protections. Washington just passed a law covering radiologic waste handlers. Construction workers exposed to asbestos, manufacturing workers handling industrial chemicals, and other first responders start lobbying for presumptive cancer laws and screening mandates. If the legal and actuarial framework holds for firefighters, states face a wave of occupational cancer legislation. Workers' comp systems either adapt to preventive care models or drown in disability claims as the workforce ages.
Historical Context
Black Lung Benefits Act (1969)
1969-presentWhat Happened
Coal miners developed pneumoconiosis—black lung disease—from inhaling coal dust for decades. The federal government initially denied the occupational link. After mounting deaths and advocacy from miners' unions, Congress passed the Coal Mine Health and Safety Act in 1969, establishing presumptive disability benefits for miners with black lung. The law shifted the burden of proof: if you mined coal long enough and had the disease, it was presumed work-related unless the employer could prove otherwise.
Outcome
Short term: Thousands of disabled miners received compensation and medical care previously denied by insurance companies.
Long term: Established the presumptive disease framework that firefighter cancer laws now follow, proving government intervention could overcome insurance industry resistance to occupational illness claims.
Why It's Relevant
Maryland's firefighter law uses the same logic coal miners fought for: if the science shows causation and you did the job long enough, the burden shifts to employers to disprove the connection.
Asbestos Litigation Wave (1970s-2000s)
1970s-2000sWhat Happened
Asbestos manufacturers knew their products caused mesothelioma and lung cancer but suppressed the evidence for decades. When the truth emerged in the 1970s, workers and their families filed tens of thousands of lawsuits. The litigation bankrupted major companies like Johns Manville and created a multi-billion-dollar trust fund system to compensate victims. Courts established medical monitoring programs allowing exposed workers to get regular screenings before developing cancer.
Outcome
Short term: Over 700,000 people filed claims, and more than $30 billion has been paid out through bankruptcy trusts.
Long term: Proved that preventive screening for high-risk occupational groups could catch cancers early and save lives, influencing modern firefighter screening programs.
Why It's Relevant
Firefighters absorb carcinogens like asbestos, benzene, and PAHs through their skin and lungs. Maryland's screening mandate applies the lesson from asbestos litigation: find it early or pay for it later.
9/11 First Responders Health Program (2010)
2001-presentWhat Happened
Firefighters, police, and rescue workers who responded to the World Trade Center attacks developed cancers and respiratory diseases from toxic dust exposure. It took nearly a decade of advocacy before Congress passed the James Zadroga 9/11 Health and Compensation Act in 2010, creating the World Trade Center Health Program. The law provides medical monitoring and treatment for 9/11 responders, with cancer added to covered conditions in 2012 after scientific studies confirmed elevated rates.
Outcome
Short term: Over 100,000 first responders enrolled in health monitoring and treatment programs.
Long term: The program became permanent in 2015 and continues today, serving as a federal precedent for occupational health programs targeting first responders exposed to carcinogens.
Why It's Relevant
The 9/11 program proved the federal government would eventually cover first responder cancer screening and treatment after sufficient advocacy. Maryland's law makes the same commitment at the state level before a mass casualty event forces the issue.