Agency for International Development v. Alliance for Open Society (2020)
The Supreme Court reviewed a requirement that organizations receiving federal HIV and AIDS money abroad adopt a policy opposing prostitution and sex traficking. Grantees said the condition forced them to espouse a message they did not hold.
The Court ruled the condition violated the First Amendment, and the funding flowed without the required policy.
The decision set a marker that government money for health work cannot come bundled with required speech.
Same funding stream, same logic: the health department cannot write a grant term that tells clinicians what to say.
