Snail Darter Halts Tellico Dam (1978)
The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 in Tennessee Valley Authority v. Hill that the Endangered Species Act barred completion of a nearly finished Tennessee dam because it would destroy the habitat of a three-inch fish called the snail darter. The project had already cost about $100 million.
Construction stopped, and a special congressional committee created by the 1978 amendments voted unanimously that the dam should not be exempted.
Congress passed a rider exempting Tellico anyway in 1979, and the dam was finished. The case established that the law's text could stop a nearly complete federal project.
Otake's order rests on the same logic: a statute written to prevent extinction requires a look at consequences before approval, not after. It also shows the remedy is political as much as legal.
