Judge Carter's Skid Row order (2021)
In a lawsuit brought by the LA Alliance for Human Rights, Judge Carter ordered the city and county to house everyone living in Skid Row within 180 days, saying local leaders were 'unable or unwilling' to solve the crisis.
The Ninth Circuit overturned the order, citing reliance on extra-record evidence. The lawsuit settled in 2022, with the city agreeing to build over 12,000 shelter beds or housing units.
It established a pattern of judicial intervention in L.A.'s homelessness crisis, showing both the potential and limits of court-ordered solutions.
Carter's willingness to intervene directly, and the subsequent settlement structure, mirrors his current role in mandating a transition from LAHSA to the county while protecting funding.
