Logo
Daily Brief
Following Why
NASCAR Kills the Knockout Playoffs After 12 Years of Controversy

NASCAR Kills the Knockout Playoffs After 12 Years of Controversy

Back-to-back championship debacles force NASCAR's biggest postseason change since 2004

Overview

NASCAR just blew up its most controversial championship system. After Joey Logano won the 2024 title with the worst average finish in Cup Series history, and Kyle Larson 'stole' the 2025 crown without leading a single lap, the sanctioning body abandoned its elimination-style playoffs for a return to 'The Chase'—the 10-race postseason format last used in 2013.

The new system rewards consistency over chaos. Gone are the nerve-wracking eliminations every three races. Gone is the winner-take-all finale that crowned champions who couldn't crack the top 10 on most Sundays. Starting in 2026, the top 16 drivers will accumulate points across 10 races, and whoever has the most at Homestead-Miami wins the title. It's the most significant championship overhaul since Brian France invented the playoffs in 2004.

Key Indicators

12
Years of elimination playoffs
The knockout format lasted from 2014 through 2025 before being scrapped
17.1
Logano's 2024 average finish
The worst average finish for any Cup Series champion in the modern era
55
New points for a win
Up from 40, the biggest win-bonus increase in NASCAR history
52.8%
Fans wanting full-season points
A 2025 poll showed only 8.5% wanted to keep the elimination format

People Involved

Steve O'Donnell
Steve O'Donnell
NASCAR President (Led championship format overhaul)
Mark Martin
Mark Martin
Hall of Fame Driver / Playoff Committee Member (Advocated for full-season points, endorsed Chase compromise)
Joey Logano
Joey Logano
Three-time Cup Series Champion (2024 championship legitimacy questioned, supports new format)
Kyle Larson
Kyle Larson
Two-time Cup Series Champion (Won 2025 title in controversial fashion)
Denny Hamlin
Denny Hamlin
60-time Race Winner / Winless in Championships (Lost sixth championship bid in 2025)
Steve Phelps
Steve Phelps
Former NASCAR Commissioner (Resigned January 6, 2026)

Organizations Involved

NA
NASCAR
Sanctioning Body
Status: Implementing major championship restructuring

The sanctioning body for America's premier stock car racing series, now reversing its most controversial postseason experiment.

Homestead-Miami Speedway
Homestead-Miami Speedway
Race Track
Status: Returning as championship finale host

The 1.5-mile oval in South Florida that hosted every NASCAR championship from 2002-2019 will reclaim the finale from Phoenix in 2026.

Timeline

  1. NASCAR Returns to 'The Chase'

    Format Change

    NASCAR announces elimination playoffs are dead. New system: 16 drivers, 10 races, no eliminations, cumulative points. Race wins jump from 40 to 55 points. 'Win and you're in' abolished.

  2. Commissioner Phelps Resigns

    Leadership

    Steve Phelps exits NASCAR after 20 years, one month after settlement in 23XI/Front Row Motorsports lawsuit. No successor named.

  3. Larson 'Steals' Championship From Hamlin

    Controversy

    Kyle Larson wins title without leading a lap. Denny Hamlin leads 208 laps but late caution from teammate Byron's flat tire forces restart. Hamlin: 'I never want to race a car again.'

  4. Fan Poll Shows 53% Want Full-Season Points

    Public Opinion

    The Athletic's Jeff Gluck poll of 30,300 fans finds 52.8% want 36-race season-long points, 27.7% want Chase return. Only 8.5% want to keep elimination playoffs.

  5. Championship Finale Returns to Homestead

    Announcement

    NASCAR announces rotating championship model. Homestead-Miami replaces Phoenix for 2026 finale after hosting from 2002-2019.

  6. NASCAR Announces Format Review

    Governance

    NASCAR confirms elimination playoffs will continue for 2025 but forms industry-wide Playoff Committee to study changes for 2026.

  7. Logano Wins Worst-Average-Finish Championship

    Controversy

    Joey Logano claims third title despite 17.1 average finish—the worst in modern era. Kyle Larson's six wins aren't enough. Criticism of format reaches fever pitch.

  8. Elimination Playoffs Introduced

    Format Change

    NASCAR announces four-round elimination system with 16 drivers. Four eliminated every three races until Championship 4 shootout at finale. 'Win and you're in' guarantees playoff spots.

  9. Brian France Creates 'The Chase'

    Format Change

    NASCAR introduces its first playoff system: top 10 drivers (plus anyone within 400 points) compete over final 10 races with points reset. Matt Kenseth's one-win 2003 championship forced the issue.

Scenarios

1

Chase Delivers Dream Champion, Format Vindicated

Discussed by: NBC Sports, Racing News, format change supporters

A driver who wins the most races and maintains consistency across the 10-race Chase claims the 2026 title. The result validates NASCAR's reversal and silences remaining critics of the format change. Fan engagement and TV ratings stabilize or improve during the postseason.

2

Championship Locked Up Early, Drama Fizzles

Discussed by: Critics of original Chase format, Jeff Gluck (The Athletic)

A dominant driver builds an insurmountable points lead with several races remaining, recreating the 'clinch before finale' problem that killed full-season racing in 2003. NASCAR faces renewed calls to add eliminations or increase win bonuses even further.

3

Close Title Fight Produces Controversial Finish Anyway

Discussed by: Denny Hamlin (podcast commentary), motorsport analysts

The 2026 finale features a close points battle, but a late-race crash, penalty, or mechanical failure hands the title to someone other than the perceived best driver. Critics argue the format still rewards luck over performance, just spread across more races.

4

Full-Season Points Movement Gains Momentum

Discussed by: Mark Martin, traditional racing advocates, 53% of polled fans

The Chase format proves a stepping stone. If 2026 results still feel arbitrary to the 53% who wanted full-season points, pressure mounts for NASCAR to eliminate playoffs entirely and return to crowning the driver with the most points across all 36 races.

Historical Context

Formula 1 Double Points Finale (2014)

November 2014

What Happened

F1 introduced double points for its Abu Dhabi season finale during the heated Lewis Hamilton-Nico Rosberg title fight. The rule was widely condemned as artificial and gimmicky, designed to manufacture drama rather than reward season-long performance.

Outcome

Short Term

Hamilton won the title anyway, but the format faced immediate backlash from teams, drivers, and fans.

Long Term

F1 abandoned double points after one season. It became a cautionary tale for manufactured championship drama.

Why It's Relevant Today

Like NASCAR's elimination playoffs, F1's double-points experiment prioritized finale drama over consistency. Both sports ultimately retreated when the artificial stakes produced outcomes fans viewed as illegitimate.

IndyCar Drops Double Points for Indy 500 (2023)

February 2023

What Happened

IndyCar eliminated double points for the Indianapolis 500 after nine seasons. The rule had been criticized by A.J. Foyt ('a gimmick') and frustrated championship contenders who saw title hopes destroyed by single-race misfortune at the Brickyard.

Outcome

Short Term

Josef Newgarden won the 2023 Indy 500 but didn't win the championship—exactly what the change was designed to allow.

Long Term

IndyCar returned to equal points for all races, prioritizing full-season performance over individual event weight.

Why It's Relevant Today

IndyCar's reversal mirrors NASCAR's 2026 decision. Both series experimented with formats that elevated specific races, then retreated when the artificial importance distorted championships.

Matt Kenseth's One-Win Championship (2003)

February-November 2003

What Happened

Matt Kenseth won a single race all season—at Las Vegas in March—then coasted to the Cup championship on consistency. Ryan Newman won eight races but finished sixth in points. The 'boring' title chase alienated fans and alarmed NASCAR leadership.

Outcome

Short Term

Kenseth was crowned champion, but ratings slumped and fans complained.

Long Term

NASCAR created The Chase in 2004 specifically to prevent one-win champions. Brian France called it necessary to 'spice up' the format.

Why It's Relevant Today

The 2003 championship created NASCAR's playoff era. The 2026 format attempts to split the difference—keeping postseason drama while eliminating the one-race finale that produced champions like 2024's Logano with the worst average finish ever.

14 Sources:
+8
NASCAR.com NBC Sports FOX Sports ESPN RACER Speedway Media Road & Track EssentiallySports Frontstretch Racing News ESPN NASCAR.com NASCAR.com NASCAR.com