Pull to refresh
Logo
Physicist derives a doubly spinning black Saturn in five dimensions

Physicist derives a doubly spinning black Saturn in five dimensions

New Capabilities

Jay Armas's preprint lets a spherical black hole and its surrounding ring each rotate in both planes available in five-dimensional spacetime

Overview

Updated 1 hour ago

In 2007, Henriette Elvang and Pau Figueras wrote down a solution to Einstein's equations describing a black hole sitting inside a black ring, a shape physicists nicknamed the black Saturn. The math only worked if both objects rotated in a single plane.

On 16 November 2026, Jay Armas of the University of Amsterdam posted a preprint that removes that limit. His six-parameter family lets each horizon spin in both independent planes available in five dimensions. In one regime, both reach extremality, the state where a black hole's Hawking temperature falls to absolute zero.

Why it matters

It describes a spacetime that probably isn't ours, but gives physicists exact solutions for testing how gravity behaves with an extra dimension.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

5
Spacetime dimensions
Three space, one time, plus one extra spatial dimension that allows a ring-shaped horizon.
6
Free parameters in the solution family
The preprint describes a six-parameter family of stationary, asymptotically flat vacuum solutions.
2
Independent rotation planes
In five dimensions an object can carry spin in two planes at once, which the 2007 solution could not express.
2
Horizons that can reach extremality together
The first regular, asymptotically flat vacuum Einstein solution with two extremal, disconnected horizons.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

People Involved

Organizations Involved

Timeline

2007 November 2026

3 events Latest: Yesterday
  1. ScienceAlert reports the result

    Latest Publication

    Michelle Starr's write-up explains the black Saturn geometry and notes the work is an unreviewed preprint.

  2. Armas posts doubly spinning black Saturn preprint

    Research

    A six-parameter family of five-dimensional vacuum solutions allows both horizons to rotate in both independent planes.

  3. First black Saturn solution published

    Research

    Henriette Elvang and Pau Figueras describe a spherical black hole encircled by a spinning black ring, limited to rotation in one plane.

Scenarios

1

Peer review puts the doubly spinning black Saturn in a journal

Likely Resolves by Q2 2028

Discussed by: The preprint itself, which carries no journal reference yet, and trade coverage noting it is unreviewed

Most arXiv preprints in this field are submitted to a journal within months. A referee would check the regularity argument and the claimed extremal limit before the result enters the citation record as established work.

2

A follow-up tests whether the doubly spinning Saturn is dynamically stable

Possible Resolves by End of 2028

Discussed by: Armas's own research summary, which states the stationary solutions do not by themselves establish dynamical stability

Finding a solution and showing it survives small perturbations are separate jobs. A numerical relativity or perturbation-theory paper would settle whether the doubly spinning configuration holds together or decays.

3

Another group finds an extremal Saturn with matched rotations

Unlikely Resolves by End of 2030

Discussed by: Armas's exact obstruction argument and earlier blackfold calculations, which both point to no mutual equilibrium at extremality

Armas shows that matching both angular velocities is incompatible with a regular axis between the horizons once both black holes are extremal. Overturning that would take a different construction, not a parameter tweak.

Historical Context

3 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

1921–1926

Kaluza-Klein theory (1921–1926)

Theodor Kaluza showed that writing Einstein's equations in five dimensions produces both gravity and electromagnetism. Oskar Klein later argued the fifth dimension is curled up far too small to detect.

Then

The proposal drew attention from relativists but no experimental confirmation.

Now

Extra dimensions became a working tool in theoretical physics, including string theory and higher-dimensional black hole research.

Why this matters now

A black Saturn requires five dimensions. That premise has gone untested since Kaluza proposed it.

2007

First black Saturn solution (2007)

Henriette Elvang and Pau Figueras published a solution in the Journal of High Energy Physics describing a spherical black hole encircled by a black ring, each with its own horizon. The ring stays open only because it spins.

Then

The configuration became a reference case for studies of higher-dimensional black hole phase diagrams.

Now

The exact solution covered rotation in one plane only, and that restriction stood for nearly two decades.

Why this matters now

Armas's preprint extends the 2007 solution to both rotation planes, which the original could not express.

1986

Myers-Perry black holes (1986)

Robert Myers and Malcolm Perry generalised rotating black holes to five or more dimensions, where an object can carry spin in two independent planes at once.

Then

The solutions became the reference point for higher-dimensional black hole physics.

Now

Their doubly spinning version remains a benchmark that any new family of solutions has to reproduce in a limiting case.

Why this matters now

The abstract lists the doubly spinning Myers-Perry black hole as a regular limit of the new black Saturn family.

Sources

(7)