Pull to refresh
Logo
University of Utah gives provost Mitzi Montoya a new role amid faculty criticism

University of Utah gives provost Mitzi Montoya a new role amid faculty criticism

Rule Changes Salt Lake City, UT local

Peter Trapa becomes deputy provost and takes over guidance for deans, academic budgeting and space, as faculty complaints about tenure and shared governance go unaddressed

Overview

Updated 1 hour ago

Mitzi Montoya became the University of Utah's provost in January 2023, hired to carry out President Taylor Randall's plan to make the school a top-10 public university. On Nov. 18, the Salt Lake Tribune reported she has a new role, after faculty spent more than a year publicly questioning her leadership.

The change shows up in a university leadership announcement. Peter Trapa, senior dean of the College of Liberal Arts & Sciences, was named deputy provost and now guides deans and handles academic budgeting and space management. Montoya's focus moves to strategic planning and expanding the university's academic reach across Salt Lake County and internationally. The faculty complaints centered on tenure decisions and on SB192, a 2024 state law that narrowed what the Academic Senate can decide.

Why it matters

The provost decides who gets hired and tenured at Utah's flagship university. That authority just moved while faculty say their voice is shrinking.

Last Monday's email for Salt Lake City, UT

Sent Nov 16. It carried:

Get next Monday's: one short email a week. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

1,415
Days Montoya served as provost
From her Jan. 3, 2023 start to the Nov. 18, 2026 report on her new role.
23
Senators backing the resolution critical of Montoya
English professor Katharine Coles introduced it; President Randall halted debate on it in February 2025.
2024
Year Utah passed SB192
The law limits faculty jurisdiction to admissions, degrees and certificates unless the president or trustees delegate more.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

People Involved

Organizations Involved

Timeline

January 2023 November 2026

5 events Latest: Yesterday
Tap a bar to jump to that date
  1. Tribune reports Montoya has a new role

    Latest News report

    The Salt Lake Tribune reports the change, noting faculty questions about her leadership over nearly four years.

  2. Trapa named deputy provost

    Appointment

    The College of Liberal Arts & Sciences dean gains oversight of deans, academic budgeting and space; Montoya's focus shifts to planning and expansion.

  3. President halts senate debate on Montoya

    Governance

    Randall stops discussion of a resolution by Katharine Coles, backed by 23 senators, accusing Montoya of misconduct in tenure decisions.

  4. Utah passes SB192

    Legislation

    The law limits faculty jurisdiction to admissions, degrees and certificates unless the president or trustees delegate more.

  5. Montoya takes over as provost

    Appointment

    She arrives from the University of New Mexico with a mandate to help Randall build a top-10 public university.

Scenarios

1

Montoya leaves the provost's office before the 2027-28 academic year

Possible Resolves by Jul 1, 2027

Discussed by: Faculty critics quoted in the Daily Utah Chronicle; the framing of the Tribune's report on her 'new role'

The portfolio shift is a soft landing, and within months the university names an interim or permanent provost. Trigger would be continued faculty pressure, a new tenure dispute, or an unfavorable legislative hearing. Montoya's title remains provost as of the November announcement, which cuts against this reading but does not rule it out.

2

Peter Trapa is named provost

Possible Resolves by End of 2027

Discussed by: Higher-education governance observers reading the deputy provost appointment as a succession step

The duties Trapa picked up, advising deans, academic budgeting, space, are the operational core of the provost's job. If Montoya exits, he is the internal candidate already doing the work. He keeps the College of Liberal Arts & Sciences deanship for now, which suggests a transitional arrangement rather than a completed handoff.

3

Utah lawmakers revisit SB192

Unlikely Resolves by Mar 15, 2027

Discussed by: Faculty governance advocates and higher-education lawyers quoted in the Chronicle

The campus fight over who decides tenure and academic policy has a legal floor set by the Legislature. Faculty argue SB192 is ambiguous about when the president must seek input. A bill clarifying or narrowing the law would move the dispute out of the senate chamber and into the Capitol.

Historical Context

2 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

2021-2022

UNC-Chapel Hill tenure fight over Nikole Hannah-Jones (2021)

North Carolina's flagship public university hired journalist Nikole Hannah-Jones to a professorship, then the board of trustees declined for months to vote on granting her tenure. Faculty and national critics objected; a legal challenge followed. The board eventually granted tenure.

Then

Hannah-Jones took the job, then left for Howard University in 2022.

Now

The episode became the standard example of trustees and administrators overriding faculty hiring recommendations, and it drew attention to how much authority sits outside faculty hands.

Why this matters now

Both cases turn on who actually controls tenure at a public university, and both show that faculty complaints rarely remove an administrator on their own. Rules and boards decide.

2014-2015

University of Illinois rescinds Steven Salaita's job offer (2014)

Illinois withdrew a tenure-track offer to Salaita after his social media posts on Gaza drew donor and political criticism. The campus faculty senate voted no confidence in chancellor Phyllis Wise, and the American Association of University Professors censured the university in 2015.

Then

Wise stepped down in 2015 amid separate controversies; the university settled with Salaita.

Now

The censure stood for years and made Illinois a reference point in arguments about administrative control over faculty appointments.

Why this matters now

It shows what faculty can and cannot do when they lose confidence in academic leadership: censure and no-confidence votes carry weight but do not by themselves change who holds the office.

Sources

(5)