Is the SpaceX a good buy
At $135 and a $1.77T valuation, SPCX is priced for perfection — Morningstar puts fair value at $780B, roughly half the IPO price, and the stock carries governance risks that even supporters concede are without precedent at this scale.
Why it matters: The Nasdaq-100 forced-buying wave (~$22-27B over the first two weeks) could push the price higher short-term, masking the valuation gap and pulling in retail investors before a more realistic reckoning.
- Morningstar initiated coverage at a $780B fair value — 55% below the IPO price — modeling Starlink and the launch business at $611B, with $170B for AI upside scenarios; analyst Nicholas Owens recommended waiting for post-listing pullbacks.
- Starlink is the only profitable segment: $1.2B operating profit in Q1 2026 on 10.3M subscribers. SpaceX as a whole posted a $4.28B net loss in Q1 2026, partly due to Starship development and the xAI acquisition burning roughly $10B/year.
- S&P 500 entry is blocked until at least mid-2027 (GAAP profitability test); the larger passive-fund buying wave won't arrive until SpaceX turns profitable on an annual basis.
- Elon Musk controls 79% of votes via dual-class shares and cannot be removed as CEO without his own consent — CalPERS, the NYC and NYS comptrollers, and AkademikerPension have all flagged this publicly, and 5% of IPO shares carry no lock-up, adding early selling pressure.
- Bulls argue the Nasdaq-100 forced buying ($22-27B) creates a near-term price floor and that Starlink's subscriber trajectory — 10.3M now, growing fast — justifies a premium multiple; bears, led by Morningstar, say even a generous Starlink DCF gets you to $780B, not $1.77T, and that historical mega-IPOs at stretched valuations average a 32% drawdown in the first year.
- On governance: some institutional investors say the dual-class structure is disqualifying (AkademikerPension has formally barred the stock); others argue SpaceX's track record — first private orbital launch, Crew Dragon, Starlink — shows Musk's operational control has created value that justifies the concession.
