Tesla promised its robotaxis would be safer than human drivers. Seven months into its Austin pilot, the company's own crash reports tell a different story: one collision per 55,000 miles, roughly nine times worse than the human average. Every crash occurred with a trained safety monitor in the vehicle who could intervene—yet the system still failed. On February 3, 2026, Tesla executives defended the program before a Senate committee, insisting autonomous systems are safer than human drivers despite the data.
The regulatory environment has intensified dramatically. Tesla removed human monitors from some Austin robotaxis on January 22, 2026, though customers report difficulty finding truly unsupervised rides. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's February 23 deadline looms for Tesla's response to its investigation into whether Full Self-Driving software commits traffic violations. Meanwhile, Congress is moving toward uniform federal standards: Democrats introduced the AV Safety Data Act (requiring transparency on miles, injuries, and stoppages) and the Stay in Your Lane Act (requiring manufacturers to define safe operating conditions). For Tesla, whose stock trades at 300 times earnings on robotaxi optimism and which shifted FSD to subscription-only on February 14, the competitive and regulatory pressure has never been greater—especially as Waymo expands globally on $16 billion in new funding.
Images from Openverse under Creative Commons licenses.
Videos from YouTube.
Interactive
Exploring all sides of a story is often best achieved with
Play.
Benjamin Franklin
(1706-1790) ·Enlightenment · wit
Fictional AI pastiche — not real quote.
"A man who promises perfection whilst still stumbling over his own feet deserves neither trust nor investment. 'Tis a curious arithmetic indeed—to value a company at three hundred times its earnings on the mere promise that machines shall outperform men, when the machines prove thrice as dangerous even with men standing ready to catch them when they fall."
100% found this insightful
Hannah Arendt
(1906-1975) ·Modernist · politics
Fictional AI pastiche — not real quote.
"The robotaxi fails not despite human oversight but through it—trained monitors whose very presence transforms vigilance into mere spectacle, rendering thought superfluous in the face of technological determinism. We witness here the bureaucratization of responsibility itself: when the crash comes, who shall we hold accountable, the algorithm or the man paid to watch it fail?"
100% found this insightful
Ever wondered what historical figures would say about today's headlines?
Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.
Click a figure to generate their perspective on this story
Debate Arena
Two rounds, two personas, one winner. You set the crossfire.
Choose Your Battle
Watch two AI personas debate this story using real evidence
Make predictions and set the crossfire to earn XP and cred
Select Your Champions
Choose one persona for each side of the debate
DEBATE TOPIC
SIDE A (PRO)
Select debater for this side:
✓
SIDE B (CON)
Select debater for this side:
✓
Choose personas with different perspectives for a more dynamic debate
VS
Get ready to make your prediction...
Round of
Claim
Evidence
Stakes
Crossfire Answer
Closing Statement
Claim
Evidence
Stakes
Crossfire Answer
Closing Statement
Your Crossfire Question
Generating arguments...
Who's Got This Round?
Make your prediction before the referee scores
Correct predictions earn +20 XP
Evidence
40%
Logic
30%
Detail
20%
Style
10%
Round Results
Your Pick!
+20 XP
Your Pick
Not this time
Evidence (40%)
Logic (30%)
Detail (20%)
Style (10%)
Overall Score
/10
Your Pick!
+20 XP
Your Pick
Not this time
Evidence (40%)
Logic (30%)
Detail (20%)
Style (10%)
Overall Score
/10
Set the Crossfire
Pick the question both personas must answer in the final round
Crafting crossfire questions...
Choosing a question earns +10 XP crossfire bonus
🏆
Total XP Earned
Cred Change
Predictions
Debate Oracle! You called every round!
Sharp Instincts! You know your debaters!
The Coin Flip Strategist! Perfectly balanced!
The Contrarian! Bold predictions!
Inverse Genius! Try betting the opposite next time!
XP Breakdown
Base completion+20 XP
Rounds played ( rounds x 5 XP)
+ XP
Correct predictions ( correct x 20 XP)
+ XP
Crossfire bonus+10 XP
Accuracy
%
Prediction History
Round
You picked:
✓✗
Keep debating to level up your credibility and unlock achievements
People Involved
Elon Musk
Chief Executive Officer, Tesla (Leading robotaxi expansion)
Organizations Involved
NA
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA)
Federal Agency
Status: Actively investigating Tesla FSD
The federal agency responsible for motor vehicle safety, currently investigating Tesla's Full Self-Driving system.
WA
Waymo
Autonomous Vehicle Company
Status: Operating fully driverless robotaxis in multiple cities
Alphabet's autonomous vehicle subsidiary, operating commercial robotaxi services without human safety drivers.
TE
Tesla, Inc.
Publicly Traded Corporation
Status: Expanding robotaxi pilot, under federal investigation
Electric vehicle manufacturer operating a limited robotaxi service in Austin with plans for rapid expansion.
Timeline
Tesla and Waymo Defend Safety Before Senate Committee
Regulatory
Tesla and Waymo executives testified before the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation on autonomous vehicle safety. Tesla's Lars Moravy stated the company would accept liability for software failures. Democrats introduced two new bills: the AV Safety Data Act (requiring NHTSA to mandate transparency on miles, injuries, and stoppages) and the Stay in Your Lane Act (requiring manufacturers to define safe operating conditions).
Waymo Raises $16 Billion at $126 Billion Valuation
Industry
Waymo secures historic funding round led by Dragoneer, DST Global, and Sequoia Capital to expand to 20+ cities globally, including London and Tokyo. The company provided 15 million rides in 2025, more than triple its 2024 volume.
Crash Data Reveals 9x Higher Rate Than Human Drivers
Data Release
Analysis of Tesla's NHTSA filings shows nine crashes across roughly 500,000 miles—one per 55,000 miles—compared to human drivers' one per 500,000 miles. All crashes occurred with safety monitors present.
Tesla Reports Q4 2025 Earnings
Financial
Tesla beats estimates but reports first annual revenue decline on record. Company announces plans for $20 billion capital expenditure in 2026 for Cybercab, Semi, and Optimus production.
Musk Claims Chase Cars Removed From Unsupervised Robotaxis
Announcement
During Tesla's Q4 earnings call, Musk states that unsupervised robotaxis no longer have chase cars following them, though customer reports suggest truly unsupervised rides remain difficult to find.
Unsupervised Robotaxi Service Pauses After Winter Storm
Operational
Tesla quietly paused unsupervised robotaxi operations after a winter storm hit Austin. Service resumed but customers report all rides still include human safety monitors despite Musk's announcement of unsupervised operation.
Tesla Removes Safety Monitors From Some Robotaxis
Milestone
Musk announces some Austin robotaxis now operate without human monitors onboard. Reports emerge of chase vehicles following the robotaxis at 15-20 feet, raising questions about true autonomy.
Tesla Announces Expansion to Seven New Cities
Announcement
At the World Economic Forum in Davos, Musk announces plans to expand robotaxi service to Dallas, Houston, Phoenix, Miami, Orlando, Tampa, and Las Vegas in first half of 2026, claiming service will be 'widespread' across the U.S. by year-end.
NHTSA Grants Tesla Extension on FSD Investigation Response
Regulatory
Federal regulators extend Tesla's deadline by five weeks to February 23, 2026, for submitting data on FSD incidents involving traffic violations. Tesla cited 8,313 internal records remaining to review and burden of responding to multiple simultaneous NHTSA investigations.
Tesla Announces FSD Shifts to Subscription-Only Model
Financial
Musk announces Tesla will eliminate the $8,000 one-time FSD purchase option on February 14, 2026, moving exclusively to a $99/month subscription model. The shift ties to Musk's compensation package requiring 10 million active FSD subscribers by 2035.
Musk Admits Tesla Needs 10 Billion Miles for Safe Unsupervised FSD
Technical
After missing his end-of-2025 deadline for unsupervised autonomy, Musk states Tesla needs approximately 10 billion miles of data to achieve safe unsupervised self-driving. The fleet is expected to reach this threshold around July 2026.
Waymo Recalls 3,067 Vehicles Over School Bus Violations
Industry
Waymo issues a recall after its Austin robotaxis passed stopped school buses an average of 1.5 times weekly. The company claimed a software fix, but five more violations occurred within two weeks.
NHTSA Expands FSD Investigation
Regulatory
Federal regulators widen their probe to cover 2.9 million Tesla vehicles after documenting 58 incidents where FSD allegedly ran red lights or crossed into opposing traffic, resulting in 14 fires and 23 injuries.
Tesla Releases FSD v14
Technical
First major FSD update in nearly a year incorporates lessons from the Austin robotaxi program, adding emergency vehicle detection, navigation-integrated routing, and improved obstacle recognition.
Four Crashes in Single Month
Incident
September sees Tesla's worst month: four crashes including an animal strike at 27 mph, a cyclist collision, a backing collision, and a parking lot incident.
First Robotaxi Crashes Reported
Incident
Tesla reports three crashes in July to NHTSA, including an SUV collision in a construction zone and a fixed-object strike that caused minor injury.
NHTSA Contacts Tesla Over Launch-Day Incidents
Regulatory
One day after launch, federal regulators reach out to Tesla following viral videos of robotaxis committing traffic violations and erratic maneuvers.
Tesla Launches Austin Robotaxi Pilot
Launch
Tesla begins offering rides in approximately 10 Model Y vehicles with human safety monitors. Videos immediately surface of erratic driving, wrong-way travel, and traffic violations.
GM Shuts Down Cruise Robotaxi Division
Industry
General Motors ends funding for Cruise after spending $10 billion, citing competitive pressures and capital needs. The 2023 pedestrian-dragging incident in San Francisco had triggered regulatory suspension and leadership purges.
Tesla Unveils Cybercab at 'We, Robot' Event
Announcement
Musk reveals 20 prototype Cybercabs—two-seater vehicles with no steering wheel or pedals—at Warner Bros. Studios in Burbank. He claims production will cost under $30,000 per vehicle.
The February 2026 NHTSA deadline results in a mandatory recall of FSD software. Tesla halts or significantly scales back its robotaxi expansion while implementing fixes. Stock drops sharply as the robotaxi timeline extends by 12-24 months, forcing investors to recalibrate valuations built on near-term autonomy revenue.
2
Tesla Expands Despite Data, Regulatory Scrutiny Intensifies
Discussed by: Electrek, industry observers, state regulators
Tesla presses forward with expansion to Texas cities and potentially California, arguing crash severity matters more than frequency. State regulators respond with new requirements—Texas's autonomous vehicle permit mandate takes effect May 2026, and California may impose additional conditions. A serious injury or fatality could trigger an immediate operational suspension similar to Cruise's 2023 shutdown.
3
Crash Rate Improves, Tesla Achieves Parity With Humans
Discussed by: Morgan Stanley, Tesla bulls, Seeking Alpha analysts
FSD v14 updates and accumulated training data reduce crash rates to human-comparable levels by mid-2026. Tesla points to the improvement as validation of its data-driven approach. Morgan Stanley's prediction of 1,000 robotaxis by year-end materializes, and the company begins generating meaningful ride-hailing revenue.
A fatality involving an unsupervised Tesla robotaxi triggers a federal investigation, potential criminal liability, and immediate operational suspension. The incident becomes Tesla's 'Uber Arizona moment,' setting back the entire autonomous vehicle industry and inviting congressional intervention through the pending SELF DRIVE Act legislation.
Historical Context
Uber Arizona Fatality (2018)
March 2018
What Happened
A modified Volvo XC90 operating under Uber's autonomous testing program struck and killed Elaine Herzberg, 49, as she walked a bicycle across a road in Tempe, Arizona. The safety driver was watching television on her phone. It was the first pedestrian death caused by a fully autonomous vehicle.
Outcome
Short Term
Uber suspended all autonomous testing nationwide. Arizona Governor Doug Ducey barred the company from further testing in the state. The safety driver was charged with negligent homicide.
Long Term
The incident forced the entire industry to slow expansion timelines and implement stricter safety protocols. It demonstrated that safety monitor presence alone does not guarantee intervention and established precedent that backup drivers can face criminal liability.
Why It's Relevant Today
Tesla's crash data shows all nine incidents occurred with trained monitors present—the same gap between assumed and actual human vigilance that contributed to the Herzberg fatality. As Tesla removes monitors, this precedent weighs heavily.
GM Cruise San Francisco Shutdown (2023)
October 2023
What Happened
A Cruise robotaxi struck a pedestrian who had been hit by another vehicle, then dragged her 20 feet while attempting to pull over. California regulators alleged Cruise executives concealed the dragging for over two weeks. The California Public Utilities Commission suspended Cruise's driverless permit.
Outcome
Short Term
Cruise halted all driverless operations nationwide. NHTSA fined the company $1.5 million. Leadership was purged and 25% of the workforce was laid off.
Long Term
GM shut down Cruise entirely in December 2024 after spending $10 billion, citing unsustainable costs and competitive pressure. The incident demonstrated how quickly a single serious crash can end a robotaxi program.
Why It's Relevant Today
Tesla faces similar regulatory scrutiny with NHTSA's February deadline and state permit requirements taking effect in May. The Cruise precedent shows how fast a robotaxi operation can collapse under combined regulatory, legal, and financial pressure.
Tesla Autopilot 2-Million-Vehicle Recall (2024)
December 2023 – February 2024
What Happened
NHTSA concluded that Tesla's Autopilot system allowed driver misuse by not adequately ensuring attention, contributing to crashes. The agency mandated Tesla's largest-ever recall—approximately 2 million vehicles—to update software and add monitoring safeguards.
Outcome
Short Term
Tesla implemented over-the-air updates adding stronger driver attention requirements. The recall was completed without major operational disruption.
Long Term
The recall established that NHTSA would intervene on driver assistance system design, not just crash response. It set precedent for the current FSD investigation covering 2.9 million vehicles.
Why It's Relevant Today
The current NHTSA investigation follows the same pattern: accumulating incident data leading to potential mandatory action. Tesla's February 2026 deadline could result in another large-scale recall affecting the robotaxi program directly.
