Reno v. ACLU (1997)
The U.S. Congress passed the Communications Decency Act to criminalize indecent material sent to minors online. Civil liberties groups sued before enforcement began, arguing the statute was too vague to comply with.
The Supreme Court struck the law down unanimously in June 1997.
The ruling set the baseline that internet speech gets full First Amendment protection, and that vague criminal statutes covering online expression face a high bar.
Mexico's article uses broad terms like "commercial scale" and "intent to deceive," the kind of language courts scrutinize when a law touches speech.
