U.S., Ukrainian and European officials met in Berlin on Nov. 19 and moved closer on a peace framework. The statement after the meeting called for legally binding guarantees after a ceasefire, a U.S.-led monitoring mechanism and a European-led force backed by Washington. [rferl.org](https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-peace-talks-us-envoys-nato-security-guarantees-russia/33902431.html)
Washington is open to an Article 5-style guarantee, based on the collective-defense clause of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), and Kushner said Russia agreed to include Europe in the next format. [rferl.org](https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-peace-talks-us-envoys-nato-security-guarantees-russia/33902431.html); [en.interfax.com.ua](https://en.interfax.com.ua/news/general/1239673.html) Russia's Sergei Ryabkov called any NATO 'quasi-membership' for Kyiv unacceptable, and Zelenskyy said officials had no shared understanding of Article 5. [rferl.org](https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-peace-talks-us-envoys-nato-security-guarantees-russia/33902431.html); [aljazeera.com](https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/20/kushner-says-russia-ok-with-nato-like-security-pact-for-ukraine-is-it) Kushner announced a new prisoner exchange for next week, while Russia launched more than 110 missiles and over 400 drones at Ukraine, hitting three Kyiv bridges and killing at least eight people. [efe.com](https://efe.com/english/latest-news/2026-11-19/us-announces-new-prisoner-exchange-between-russia-and-ukraine-next-week/); [bbc.co.uk](https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6x29gn4pdn9o); [apnews.com](https://apnews.com/article/ukraine-russia-war-kyiv-attacks-putin-crimea-433e18f00cbd37a2a9da94e60fce0e07)
Why it matters
Whether binding guarantees and a prisoner swap can survive Russian attacks and put Ukraine on a path to a ceasefire.
Questions about this story
Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.
No questions yet — be the first to ask.
Key Indicators
Nov. 19
Berlin meeting held
The Coalition of the Willing met with Ukrainian and U.S. officials; the joint statement called for legally binding guarantees after a ceasefire.
Europe
Next talks widen
Kushner said Russia agreed to a multilateral format including European countries, and Merz expected Europe to take part in future negotiations.
Article 5
Guarantee model debated
Washington was open to an Article 5-style guarantee; Russia rejected NATO 'quasi-membership' and Zelenskyy said the term was not commonly understood.
Next week
Prisoner exchange announced
Kushner said a new exchange would take place next week; Kyiv said it was still waiting for Russia's list.
3
Kyiv bridges hit
Russia struck the Podilsko-Voskresensky, Darnytskyi and Southern bridges in Kyiv during a wider attack on Nov. 20.
Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.
Jane Addams
(1860-1935) ·Progressive Era · social reform
Fictional AI pastiche — not real quote.
"The architects of peace gather in grand halls—Paris, Davos, Abu Dhabi—while the actual inhabitants of the disputed territories remain conspicuously absent from these deliberations about their own fate. One might observe that 15,000 troops are being pledged to secure a peace, yet I wonder how many social workers, teachers, and rebuilders are included in these guarantees? True security cannot be imposed by armed sentries alone; it must grow from the capacity of ordinary people to resume their daily bread-winning, their neighborhood associations, their small democracies—none of which are negotiable in percentages of the Donbas."
100% found this insightful
Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.
68 events
Latest: 2 days ago
Showing 8 of 68
JK to step
Tap a bar to jump to that date
Jump to
November 2026
Article 5-Style Guarantee Plan Draws Russian Rejection
LatestStatement
Kushner said Washington had made Moscow comfortable with an Article 5-style guarantee and Trump was open to it. Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said any 'quasi-membership' in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) for Kyiv was unacceptable; Zelenskyy said there was no shared understanding of Article 5. [rferl.org](https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-peace-talks-us-envoys-nato-security-guarantees-russia/33902431.html); [aljazeera.com](https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/20/kushner-says-russia-ok-with-nato-like-security-pact-for-ukraine-is-it)
Macron Urges Allies to Reopen NATO Question
Statement
Macron said allies should reconsider Ukraine's accession to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization and called for urgent air-defense systems and interceptors. [rferl.org](https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-peace-talks-us-envoys-nato-security-guarantees-russia/33902431.html)
Russia Strikes Kyiv Bridges and Rail Sites
Military
Days after Ukraine damaged the Crimean Bridge, Russia fired more than 110 missiles and over 400 drones at Ukraine, hitting three Kyiv bridges and railway stations. Reports put the death toll at eight or nine; the Podilsko-Voskresensky, Darnytskyi and Southern bridges were closed. [bbc.co.uk](https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6x29gn4pdn9o); [apnews.com](https://apnews.com/article/ukraine-russia-war-kyiv-attacks-putin-crimea-433e18f00cbd37a2a9da94e60fce0e07)
U.S. Envoys Say Trump Pressed Putin on Talks
Statement
Witkoff and Kushner told European leaders in Berlin that Trump pressed Putin to move on peace talks and said now was the time for a deal, according to a European official cited by Axios. [axios.com](https://www.axios.com/2026/11/20/trump-pushes-putin-ukraine-war-deal)
Berlin Meeting Produces Joint Call for Binding Guarantees
Diplomatic
The Coalition of the Willing, hosted by Friedrich Merz and attended by Zelenskyy, Witkoff and Kushner, called for legally binding guarantees after a ceasefire. Leaders also backed U.S.-led monitoring, a European-led force supported by Washington, more pressure on Moscow, a winter energy ceasefire and protection for Black Sea food exports. [rferl.org](https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-peace-talks-us-envoys-nato-security-guarantees-russia/33902431.html)
Russia Agrees to Multilateral Format, Kushner Says
Diplomatic
Kushner said Russia agreed to join a negotiation format that includes European countries and that Trump would not impose a unilateral deal. Merz also said future talks should include Europe, with the United Arab Emirates floated as a possible venue. [en.interfax.com.ua](https://en.interfax.com.ua/news/general/1239673.html); [rferl.org](https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-peace-talks-us-envoys-nato-security-guarantees-russia/33902431.html)
New Prisoner Exchange Announced
Diplomatic
Kushner said a new Russia-Ukraine prisoner exchange would take place next week, following the deal reached in Abu Dhabi. The Kremlin said the exchange was in its final stage, while Zelenskyy said Kyiv was still waiting for Russia's list. [efe.com](https://efe.com/english/latest-news/2026-11-19/us-announces-new-prisoner-exchange-between-russia-and-ukraine-next-week/); [mezha.net](https://mezha.net/eng/news/mezha-091456f170eb505ad7477976_zelensky-_ukraine_is/); [newsdiff.io](https://newsdiff.io/en/developments/19619)
Ukraine, U.S. and European Officials Hold Online Talks
Diplomatic
Zelenskyy called the talks with U.S. envoys and European representatives 'not easy,' then said participants agreed to meet in Berlin with the Coalition of the Willing. France, Germany, Britain, Italy and Poland took part; Moscow said it had not agreed to expand the format.
Zelenskyy Says Prisoner Exchange Is Being Prepared
Diplomatic
Zelenskyy said intelligence channels were already communicating and Ukraine was ready to deliver results in coming weeks. He earlier told reporters as many as 1,300 people could be exchanged, with timing depending on Russia and U.S. communication.
Kyiv Bridges Hit as Strikes Escalate
Military
Kyiv Mayor Vitali Klitschko said preliminary reports indicated the North and South bridges across the Dnipro River had been hit. Ukraine also struck the Crimea Bridge and targeted oil refineries, according to Russian defence ministry data cited by Al Jazeera.
U.S. Envoys Meet Putin in Moscow
Diplomatic
Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner met Putin in the Kremlin after the Abu Dhabi talks ended, the AP reported. The Kremlin gave no detailed readout.
Russia Strikes Kyiv Hours After Talks End
Military
Russia fired ballistic missiles and 123 attack drones at Kyiv, killing one person and injuring five, Mayor Vitaliy Klitschko said. Ukraine said it shot down 94 drones and no missiles; Russia said it targeted drone production sites and power substations.
Zelenskyy Sees 'Window of Opportunity' Before 2027
Diplomatic
Speaking in Dublin, Zelenskyy said participants in the talks genuinely want a result before 2027 and that U.S. envoys should return from Moscow with "specifics." He said territory remained the hardest issue.
Abu Dhabi Talks End With Largest POW Exchange Deal
Diplomatic
Russia and Ukraine agreed to the war's largest prisoner exchange, with TASS reporting more than 1,000 people on each side. Negotiators made no breakthrough on territory or a ceasefire.
Trilateral Talks Resume in Abu Dhabi
Diplomatic
Russian, Ukrainian and U.S. delegations met for the first time since February. Zelensky called the first day "constructive and quite substantive"; Rubio called it "very productive."
October 2026
Abu Dhabi Talks Still Unscheduled
Diplomatic
Zelenskyy said the trilateral talks should fall between Nov. 6 and 10, but no date was set. Washington is waiting on Middle East developments before fixing one.
Oleshky Truce Takes Effect
Military
The six-day ceasefire in and around Oleshky began early Oct. 27, Moscow's timing. Officials said it held through its first day and night.
Local Ceasefire Agreed for Oleshky
Diplomatic
Russia and Ukraine agreed to pause fighting in the Russian-occupied town to allow aid and civilian evacuations. Reuters reported it would start Oct. 27; the White House said Oct. 29. Melania Trump served as intermediary.
Russia and Ukraine Swap 270 Prisoners
Diplomatic
Each side returned 270 servicemen in the first exchange since August, Russia's Defense Ministry said. Zelenskyy called it a 'very important result.'
Russia Strikes Energy Grid as Talks Restart
Military
Russian attacks knocked out power for more than 500,000 people across six regions, Ukraine's Energy Ministry said, even as diplomacy resumed.
Trilateral Technical Talks Set for Abu Dhabi
Diplomatic
Zelenskyy said negotiators from Ukraine, Russia and the United States would meet at the technical level in the first half of November in Abu Dhabi. A U.S. official said the next talks could be in Abu Dhabi or Switzerland.
Russia Agrees to Restart Trilateral Talks After Nov. 10
Diplomatic
Kremlin foreign affairs adviser Yuri Ushakov said Putin agreed in principle to resume three-way talks with Kyiv and Washington after meeting U.S. envoy Steve Witkoff in St. Petersburg. The talks would focus on a postwar security system for Russia and Ukraine.
April 2026
Russia and Ukraine Agree to 32-Hour Orthodox Easter Ceasefire
Diplomatic
Putin ordered Russian forces to halt combat on all fronts from 4 p.m. Moscow time on April 11 through April 12. Zelenskyy said Ukraine would reciprocate, and both sides called for an Easter without threats.
February 2026
Witkoff Scheduled to Meet Zelenskyy's Security Chief Umerov
Diplomatic
US envoy Steve Witkoff was due to meet Ukraine's security chief Rustem Umerov on Feb. 26, 2026. No outcome of that meeting was reported.
UN General Assembly Adopts Ukraine Peace Resolution as US Abstains
Diplomatic
The UN General Assembly voted 107-12-51 on a resolution titled 'Support for lasting peace in Ukraine' on the fourth anniversary of Russia's full-scale invasion. The resolution reaffirms Ukraine's sovereignty and territorial integrity and calls for immediate ceasefire, POW exchanges, and return of forcibly transferred civilians. The US abstained after failing to remove references to Ukraine's territorial integrity; China, India, and UAE also abstained.
Canada Announces C$2 Billion Military Aid Package for Ukraine
Military
Canada announced a C$2 billion ($1.4 billion USD) military aid package for Ukraine and expanded sanctions against Russia, including measures targeting Moscow's 'shadow fleet' and implementing a lower oil price cap.
Zelenskyy Warns 80% of Ukraine Lacks Air Defense Against Ballistic Missiles
Military
President Zelenskyy stated that approximately 80% of Ukraine lacks protection against Russian ballistic missiles, renewing urgent calls for additional air defense systems including Patriot air defense systems.
Zelenskyy Addresses Munich, Meets Rubio Amid Air Defense Push
Diplomatic
Zelenskyy speaks at Munich Security Conference with Rutte and Metsola, emphasizing US-backed guarantees; expected talks with Rubio occur as Europeans pledge anti-aircraft aid against Russian drones; Putin warns he 'cannot let go of war' per Zelenskyy.
Rubio at Munich: Issues Narrowed, Geneva Talks Confirmed
Diplomatic
US Secretary Rubio tells Munich conference that Russia-Ukraine issues have 'narrowed' with progress made, but hardest questions remain; confirms Witkoff/Kushner to lead trilateral talks in Geneva February 17-18; skips informal Ukraine meeting attended by European leaders.
Russia Launches Massive Energy Infrastructure Strike
Military
Russia conducted another large-scale attack on Ukrainian energy infrastructure overnight February 6-7, as US urges faster peace talks aiming for March 2026 deal and May referendum while Russia demands capitulation and refuses extended ceasefire.
Ukraine-Russia Agree to Exchange 314 POWs After Abu Dhabi Talks
Diplomatic
Second round of trilateral talks concludes with agreement to swap 157 prisoners each (314 total), first such exchange in five months; US envoy Witkoff calls talks 'detailed and productive' while noting significant work remains on territory and security guarantees. Ukrainian negotiator Umerov describes discussions as 'substantive'; Russian envoy Dmitriev reports 'progress and positive movement.'
Zelenskyy Announces 55,000 Ukrainian Troops Killed in Combat
Military
Ukrainian president reveals updated casualty figures showing 55,000 Ukrainian soldiers killed since Russia's full-scale invasion began, up from 46,000 reported in early 2025. Zelenskyy warns that Ukraine needs genuine progress toward peace, not terms that allow Russia to exploit advantages and continue strikes.
US and Russia Agree to Reestablish Military-to-Military Dialogue
Diplomatic
During Abu Dhabi talks, US Gen. Alexus Grynkewich and senior Russian military officials agreed to restore high-level military communication suspended since 2021. The restored channel will provide consistent military-to-military contact to prevent accidental escalation and support peace negotiations.
Zelenskyy Announces Next Round of Talks Likely in United States
Diplomatic
Ukrainian president states that further meetings are planned for the near future, likely in America, following two days of productive trilateral talks in Abu Dhabi. Zelenskyy expects his negotiation team to return to Kyiv for full debriefing on discussions.
Second Round of Abu Dhabi Talks Rescheduled to February 4-5
Diplomatic
Kremlin confirms next trilateral talks moved from February 1 to February 4-5 in Abu Dhabi to adjust schedules of all participants; Russia reportedly sending more senior negotiators than first round.
Second Round of Trilateral Talks Scheduled in Abu Dhabi
Diplomatic
US officials confirm next round of three-way negotiations will begin February 1 in UAE, continuing discussions on territorial parameters and ceasefire conditions.
January 2026
US Envoy Witkoff Holds Separate Talks with Russian Envoy Dmitriev in Florida
Diplomatic
US Special Envoy Steve Witkoff meets Russian envoy Kirill Dmitriev in Florida without Ukrainian representatives present; calls talks "productive and constructive." Treasury Secretary Bessent and Jared Kushner also attend. Meeting occurs one day before scheduled Abu Dhabi trilateral talks.
Trump Announces Putin Agreed to Pause Kyiv Attacks Through February 1
Diplomatic
President Trump says Putin agreed to his personal request to halt strikes on Kyiv for one week through February 1 due to extreme cold and to "create favorable conditions for negotiations." Kremlin confirms Trump's request but terms remain unclear; ongoing attacks reported despite announced pause.
Zelenskyy Invites Putin to Kyiv for Direct Talks
Diplomatic
Ukrainian president invites Putin to Kyiv for negotiations "if he dares," saying he's ready for any format but will not go to Moscow or Belarus. Clarifies there is "no official agreement on a ceasefire" and no direct dialogue between Ukraine and Russia on the pause, calling Trump's initiative "an opportunity rather than an agreement."
Energy Infrastructure Pause Announced Amid Confusion
Military
Zelenskyy says both Ukraine and Russia began weeklong pause in attacks on energy infrastructure amid plummeting winter temperatures. Kremlin claims Moscow only agreed to pause until Sunday; disagreement persists on duration and scope of energy ceasefire.
Reciprocal Energy Ceasefire Takes Effect Through February 3
Military
Despite confusion over terms of Trump's announced Kyiv pause, Zelenskyy confirms reciprocal energy infrastructure ceasefire in effect through February 3, saying "If Russia does not strike us, we will take corresponding steps." Ukraine refrains from hitting Russian energy targets; Russia fires ballistic missile and 100+ drones but Kremlin confirms compliance with energy pause.
Rubio Confirms Donetsk Territorial Issue Is Last Major Obstacle
Statement
US Secretary of State tells Senate Foreign Relations Committee that "the one remaining item" in peace negotiations is "the territorial claim on Donetsk in particular," calling it "a very difficult" gap to bridge. Confirms security guarantees agreed "from our side" but notes they would only apply after conflict ends.
Ukraine Says Russia Sending More Senior Negotiators to Next Round
Diplomatic
Ukrainian foreign minister describes Russian officials involved in talks resuming February 1 in UAE as "much more serious than before," signaling increased Kremlin engagement in peace process.
CSIS Report Warns Combined Casualties Could Reach 2 Million
Military
Center for Strategic and International Studies analysis estimates Russia has suffered 1.2 million casualties (325,000 deaths) and Ukraine 500,000-600,000 casualties (140,000 deaths), with combined total potentially reaching 2 million by spring 2026—more losses than any major power in any war since World War II.
Reports Emerge: US Ties Security Guarantees to Ukraine Ceding Donbas
Diplomatic
Financial Times reports Trump administration has indicated to Ukraine that US security guarantees are contingent on Kyiv first agreeing peace deal involving ceding Donbas region to Russia, according to eight people familiar with talks. Ukraine wants guarantees confirmed before giving up land; Washington signals commitments depend on accommodation with Russia. White House deputy press secretary calls reports "totally false."
Kremlin Calls Talks 'Constructive' While Reiterating Territorial Demands
Statement
Kremlin spokesman Peskov describes Abu Dhabi talks as constructive but warns against expecting quick results, stating territorial issue is "of fundamental importance" for Russia. Russia reiterates demand that Ukraine withdraw from all of Donbas.
Zelenskyy Announces US Security Agreement '100% Ready' for Signing
Diplomatic
Ukrainian president announces in Vilnius that US security guarantees document is complete and awaiting formal signing ceremony, after which it will go to US Congress and Ukrainian parliament for ratification.
First US-Ukraine-Russia Trilateral Talks Begin in Abu Dhabi
Diplomatic
First direct three-way negotiations since February 2022 invasion commence, with Ukrainian Defense Minister Umerov and intelligence chief Budanov meeting Russian General Staff Chief Kostyukov and US envoys Witkoff and Kushner. Talks scheduled for two days focusing on territorial parameters for ending conflict.
Trump and Zelenskyy meet at World Economic Forum in Davos; Zelenskyy announces security guarantee terms finalized and deal nearly ready on economic recovery. US envoy Witkoff declares negotiations 'down to one issue'—territorial control of Donbas.
Paris Declaration Signed with Concrete Security Commitments
Diplomatic
Coalition of the Willing summit in Paris produces formal Declaration on Robust Security Guarantees including US-led ceasefire monitoring mechanism, continued military assistance, and multinational force deployment. UK and France sign separate declaration with Zelenskyy committing to deploy up to 15,000 troops combined and establish military hubs across Ukraine.
December 2025
Macron Announces Paris Summit for Early January
Announcement
Coalition of the Willing to meet in Paris to finalize concrete security contributions.
Russia Claims Ukrainian Attack on Putin's Residence
Statement
Russia alleges Ukraine attacked Putin's residence in Novgorod with 91 drones hours after Mar-a-Lago talks; Zelenskyy rejects claim as "complete fabrication" to derail peace negotiations.
Poll Shows 76% of Ukrainians Reject Territorial Concessions
Domestic
Survey published by Democratic Initiatives Foundation shows overwhelming Ukrainian opposition to recognizing occupied territories as Russian, with regional variations from 2% in west to 22% in center.
Russia Claims 6,460 Square Kilometers Seized in 2025
Military
Chief of General Staff Gerasimov reports Russian forces captured 6,460 sq km and 334 settlements in 2025; ISW disputes claim, estimating ~4,700 sq km actually seized.
Trump pushes through a February deadline deal trading Ukrainian territorial concessions for 15-30 year security guarantees backed by congressional approval. Europe deploys 10,000+ peacekeeping troops to a demilitarized zone along frozen frontlines. Russia accepts because it locks in territorial gains while avoiding NATO expansion. Ukraine accepts because Article 5-like guarantees from US, UK, France, and Germany feel stronger than endless war with retreating defenses. The framework survives Trump leaving office because troops on the ground and legislative commitments create institutional stickiness. Key trigger: Paris summit produces binding troop commitments from Coalition members, convincing Kyiv the guarantees won't evaporate.
2
Putin Rejects Deal, Grinds Forward for Maximal Gains
Russia keeps stalling negotiations while forces advance 150+ square miles monthly, betting Trump's patience runs out and European unity fractures. Putin calculates that Ukrainian defenses—already retreating faster than any point in the war—will collapse further by spring 2026, giving Russia better terms than any current deal. He publicly engages in talks to avoid blame for failure while privately ordering generals to take remaining Donbas by force. Trump eventually walks away as promised, Europeans can't fill the gap, and Ukraine is forced to accept worse terms in late 2026. Key trigger: Russia continues advancing in January-February despite negotiations, signaling military strategy over diplomatic resolution.
3
Deal Collapses Like Budapest—Russia Violates Within Five Years
A ceasefire is signed with security guarantees that look impressive on paper. European peacekeepers deploy to the demilitarized zone. Ukraine begins reconstruction with Western investment. But when Russia tests the boundaries in 2028 or 2030—a border incursion, a drone strike, supporting separatists—the US response is tepid, European coalition members disagree on activation, and the guarantees prove hollow. Ukraine, having demilitarized per agreement terms, faces renewed invasion without the military capacity it sacrificed for peace. The deal becomes a cautionary tale like Budapest: promises from great powers aren't worth the paper when territorial integrity doesn't align with their interests. Key trigger: Guarantees aren't enshrined in binding treaties requiring parliamentary ratification, leaving them vulnerable to political changes.
4
Ukrainian Referendum Rejects Deal, War Continues
Unlikely
Discussed by: Al Jazeera, Kyiv Post analysts noting Zelenskyy's referendum requirement
Zelenskyy insists any territorial concessions require a national referendum after a 60-day ceasefire, per his December statements. The referendum is held in spring 2026, and Ukrainian voters—watching Russian forces occupy 20% of their country—reject territorial concessions by wide margins. The peace process collapses. Trump declares Ukraine ungrateful and reduces support. European allies increase aid but can't replace US capacity. The war grinds into 2027 with no clear path to resolution. Ukraine faces a choice between fighting with diminishing resources or accepting worse terms without democratic legitimacy. Key trigger: Russia refuses the 60-day ceasefire needed for referendum, or holds one that produces a "No" vote.
5
November Technical Talks Produce a Narrow Framework, Not a Final Deal
Possible
Resolves by Jan 31, 2027
Discussed by: Reuters, AP and Washington Post analysts covering the restart
U.S., Ukrainian and Russian negotiators met in Abu Dhabi in early November after Moscow agreed to restart talks following Nov. 10. They agreed on the war's largest prisoner exchange but made no progress on territory or a ceasefire, leaving a final settlement to 2027.
6
Berlin Meeting Sets European Position but Russia Keeps Talks Trilateral
Possible
Resolves by Dec 19, 2026
Discussed by: Nov. 17 statements by Zelenskyy and Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov
After Nov. 19, this looked less likely: Kushner said Russia agreed to a format including Europe, and the Berlin meeting produced a common European position. Territory, borders and the meaning of Article 5-style guarantees remained unresolved.
7
Article 5-Style Guarantee Breaks the Deadlock
Possible
Resolves by End of 2026
Discussed by: Kushner's Nov. 20 comments and European leaders' Berlin statement
The next round turns the Article 5-style idea into a written security package for Ukraine without North Atlantic Treaty Organization membership. A European-led force, U.S. backing and monitoring give Kyiv enough assurance to discuss borders, while Moscow accepts the language as a substitute for membership.
8
Europe Joins the Next Round but Guarantees Stay Vague
Likely
Resolves by End of 2026
Discussed by: Kushner's remarks on the format and Merz's comments after Berlin
The next talks include European countries, as Kushner said Moscow agreed, but the sides leave troops, borders and ceasefire terms for later. The prisoner exchange moves ahead while attacks continue.
Historical Context
3 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.
1 of 3
1994-2014
Budapest Memorandum (1994)
Ukraine surrendered the world's third-largest nuclear arsenal in exchange for security assurances from the US, UK, and Russia guaranteeing its sovereignty and territorial integrity. The memorandum was carefully drafted to avoid implying military commitments—"assurances" not "guarantees." In 2014, Russia annexed Crimea. In 2022, Russia launched a full-scale invasion. The US and UK provided sanctions and weapons, but no military intervention. Ukraine tried three times to convene consultations under the memorandum; all failed.
Then
Successful nuclear non-proliferation; Ukraine became non-nuclear state under NPT.
Now
Complete failure to protect Ukraine's territorial integrity; memorandum became symbol of worthless security promises.
Why this matters now
The single biggest obstacle to Ukraine trusting new security guarantees—why Zelenskyy demands binding Article 5-like commitments, not political assurances.
2 of 3
1995-2004
Dayton Agreement and IFOR Peacekeeping (1995)
After 3.5 years of Bosnian War, US-brokered Dayton Agreement ended fighting and established a complex power-sharing government. NATO deployed 60,000 peacekeeping troops (IFOR) with robust rules of engagement to enforce military aspects of the agreement. The Implementation Force had clear command structure, overwhelming military capability versus local forces, and political unity among NATO members. Peacekeepers remained for nearly a decade, preventing conflict resumption.
Then
Immediate end to active combat; peacekeepers successfully separated forces and enforced ceasefire.
Now
Fragile peace held for 30 years despite ethnic tensions; Bosnia remains dysfunctional but not at war.
Why this matters now
The model Coalition of the Willing references—but Ukraine faces a nuclear-armed adversary, not local militias, making enforcement exponentially harder.
3 of 3
1953-present
Korean Armistice and DMZ (1953-present)
After three years of Korean War, armistice agreement established a demilitarized zone patrolled by both sides and neutral nations. No peace treaty was ever signed—technically still at war. The DMZ has been monitored by UN forces, including Swiss and Swedish peacekeepers, for 72 years. Massive US troop presence in South Korea (28,500 currently) provided credible deterrence. Multiple violations and incidents occurred, but full-scale war never resumed.
Then
Ended active hostilities and prisoner exchanges; created 2.5-mile-wide buffer zone.
Now
Longest-standing armistice in modern history; frozen conflict prevented from reigniting by permanent military presence and US security guarantee.
Why this matters now
Shows demilitarized zones can work with credible enforcement—but required permanent US troop deployment and acceptance of indefinite division, not eventual reunification.