Makani Technologies Collapse (2020)
February 2020What Happened
After 13 years of development and acquisition by Google in 2013, Alphabet shut down Makani Technologies, the most prominent Western effort to commercialize airborne wind energy. The company had developed a 600-kilowatt crosswind kite system but failed during a 2019 test flight off Norway's coast, with the generator crashing into the sea. Alphabet cited a 'longer and riskier' path to commercialization than anticipated.
Outcome
Makani released its entire patent portfolio and 13 years of technical data as open source, allowing competitors to build on its research.
The collapse created widespread skepticism about airborne wind energy's commercial viability, leaving the field without a major Western champion. SAWES has explicitly positioned its success as vindication of the technology Makani couldn't commercialize.
Why It's Relevant Today
SAWES's achievement directly addresses the failure that ended Makani: generating megawatt-scale power that Makani never reached. China's state-backed approachβuniversity partnerships, sustained fundingβoffers a different development model than Silicon Valley's moonshot style.
