Brandon Mayfield and the Madrid bombing fingerprint (2004)
After the March 11, 2004 train bombings in Madrid, the FBI ran a latent fingerprint from a bag of detonators through its database and got a match to Brandon Mayfield, a lawyer in Oregon. Two FBI examiners and an outside examiner confirmed it. Mayfield was arrested May 6, 2004 and held as a material witness for two weeks while Spanish police said the print belonged to an Algerian national.
The FBI released Mayfield on May 20, 2004 and apologized. A Justice Department Inspector General report in January 2006 faulted the bureau's examiners for confirmation bias.
The case became the standard example of what happens when a database hit is treated as an answer, and it pushed latent-print units toward more independent verification.
Same failure shape: a technical match declared an identification, with no meaningful human check in between. The Kentucky order addresses the software version of that error.
