Amyloid Hypothesis Dominance (1991-2021)
1991-2021What Happened
For 30 years, virtually all Alzheimer's drug development focused on clearing amyloid-β plaques from the brain. The amyloid cascade hypothesis, proposed by Hardy and Allsop in 1991, argued that amyloid buildup triggered everything else—including tau tangles. Pharmaceutical companies invested tens of billions of dollars in anti-amyloid antibodies, secretase inhibitors, and vaccines.
Outcome
A 99.6% failure rate. Drugs like gantenerumab and semagacestat cleared amyloid but didn't slow cognitive decline. Some made patients worse.
Lecanemab and donanemab eventually showed modest benefits (27-35% slowing) but only in early-stage patients with low tau. The failures forced recognition that tau—not amyloid—drives cognitive decline.
Why It's Relevant Today
The OTULIN discovery offers a fundamentally different approach: instead of clearing proteins after they accumulate, prevent their production entirely. This upstream intervention could bypass the limitations that plagued amyloid-targeting drugs.
