San Francisco's facial recognition ban (2019)
San Francisco's Board of Supervisors voted 8-1 to ban city departments, including police, from using facial recognition technology, the first US city to do so. The ordinance required all surveillance technologies to have approved policies before use.
City agencies were barred from facial recognition use, and the vote set off a national wave of similar bans.
Within five years, SF reversed course under new leadership, expanding drone and camera authority through Proposition E while keeping the policy-approval framework the 2019 ordinance created.
The swing from facial recognition ban to Flock embrace frames today's debate: both sides use the 2019 ordinance's framework to argue for or against stricter controls on surveillance.
