Betsy DeVos Confirmation (2017)
2017-02What Happened
Education Secretary nominee Betsy DeVos became the first Cabinet nominee in history to require a vice presidential tie-breaking vote. Vice President Mike Pence cast the deciding 51st vote after two Republicans (Collins and Murkowski) joined all Democrats in opposition. DeVos faced intense criticism over lack of public school experience and controversial education privatization views.
Outcome
DeVos served full term despite contentious confirmation and ongoing protests.
Set precedent that VP tie-breaking vote could confirm Cabinet members, expanded later with Hegseth in 2025.
Why It's Relevant Today
The 2017 DeVos confirmation established the playbook Trump used in 2025âpushing controversial nominees through on party-line votes with VP as insurance. Hegseth's 2025 confirmation became only the second such instance.
