Pull to refresh
Logo
Federal fight for state voter rolls

Federal fight for state voter rolls

Rule Changes

The Justice Department lost all 28 district court rulings on its voter data demands; it has until December 11 to ask the Supreme Court to revive its Michigan case, while New Hampshire's election chief faces a criminal probe

Overview

Updated Nov 11

The Justice Department wants unredacted voter files from every state that keeps registration records, including names, birth dates, driver's license numbers and partial Social Security numbers, for roughly 160 million registered voters. It sued 31 jurisdictions that refused. Judges have dismissed 28 of those suits, Oklahoma settled, and no court has ruled for the department.

A federal judge in Delaware threw out the department's suit on November 10, the 28th dismissal. In Los Angeles, Judge David Carter closed the California ballot case after DOJ dropped it, writing that the suit 'attempted to disrupt an ongoing election.' DOJ now has until December 11 to ask the Supreme Court to review its Michigan loss, after Justice Brett Kavanaugh extended the deadline. New Hampshire's secretary of state is under criminal investigation for refusing to hand over his state's data.

Why it matters

The fight decides whether the federal government can see the personal data of 160 million voters and pressure states over election results.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

31
Jurisdictions Sued
States plus D.C. facing DOJ lawsuits for refusing to turn over voter files
18
States Sharing Data
States that provided unredacted voter data to DOJ before the policy was vacated
28
Cases Dismissed
Lawsuits dismissed; 1 settled and 3 still pending
160M+
Voters Affected
Approximate number of registered voters whose data is being sought
1
Criminal Probe of an Election Official
New Hampshire's secretary of state is under federal criminal investigation for refusing to hand over voter data

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Benjamin Franklin

Benjamin Franklin

(1706-1790) · Enlightenment · wit

Fictional AI pastiche — not real quote.

"A government that demands the private particulars of every citizen in the name of protecting elections reminds me of the man who burns down his house to roast a pig. One wonders whether the fox claiming to guard the henhouse grows more dangerous when he insists all hens be catalogued, numbered, and centrally registered for their own safety."

Ayn Rand

Ayn Rand

(1905-1982) · Cold War · philosophy

Fictional AI pastiche — not real quote.

"The spectacle of federal bureaucrats demanding a national registry of citizens while states invoke their sovereignty is less a constitutional crisis than a turf war between rival gangs of power-lusters—each claiming to protect your rights while scrambling to catalog you like inventory in a warehouse. The only principle at stake is which level of government gets to treat free individuals as livestock to be counted, tracked, and managed."

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

People Involved

Harmeet Dhillon
Harmeet Dhillon
Assistant Attorney General, DOJ Civil Rights Division
Reportedly fired by President Trump in early November 2026; the voter-list policy she oversaw was vacated nationwide and DOJ is appealing that ruling to the D.C. Circuit
Brad Raffensperger
Brad Raffensperger
Georgia Secretary of State
Defendant in dismissed lawsuit; running for governor
DC
David O. Carter
U.S. District Judge, Central District of California
Presided over the California ballot case and closed it on November 10, after DOJ dropped the suit
C. Ashley Royal
C. Ashley Royal
Senior U.S. District Judge, Middle District of Georgia
Dismissed Georgia case on venue grounds
Susan Beals
Susan Beals
Virginia Elections Commissioner
Defendant in DOJ lawsuit filed January 17, 2026
Josh Kaul
Josh Kaul
Wisconsin Attorney General
Defending state against DOJ lawsuit; filed motion to dismiss
Stephanie Thomas
Stephanie Thomas
Connecticut Secretary of State
Defendant in DOJ lawsuit; ACLU intervened on behalf of Connecticut voter January 29
Pam Bondi
Pam Bondi
U.S. Attorney General
Leading DOJ voter data campaign; drew accusations of coercion over Minnesota
Steve Simon
Steve Simon
Minnesota Secretary of State
Refused DOJ demands; called Bondi letter coercive
Alex Padilla
Alex Padilla
U.S. Senator (D-CA), Ranking Member, Senate Rules Committee
Leading Congressional opposition to DOJ voter data campaign
Tim Walz
Tim Walz
Minnesota Governor
Received Bondi letter conditioning ICE withdrawal on data provision
Kash Patel
Kash Patel
FBI Director
Defended Fulton County search warrant execution
JQ
Jason Reding Quinones
Federal prosecutor
Resigned from the Justice Department on November 6, 2026
DS
Dave Scanlan
New Hampshire Secretary of State
Under federal criminal investigation for refusing to hand over the state's unredacted voter list; also defending a civil case on appeal at the First Circuit

Organizations Involved

DOJ Civil Rights Division
DOJ Civil Rights Division
Federal Agency Division
Plaintiff in the voter data lawsuits; 28 suits dismissed, one settled, three pending; its voter-list policy was vacated nationwide and is on appeal; it has until December 11 to ask the Supreme Court to review its Michigan loss

The DOJ division responsible for enforcing federal civil rights laws, now leading litigation to compel states to surrender voter registration data.

Brennan Center for Justice
Brennan Center for Justice
Legal Advocacy Organization
Tracking litigation; advising states

A nonpartisan law and policy institute that maintains the most comprehensive public tracker of the DOJ voter data demands and lawsuits.

Wisconsin Elections Commission
Wisconsin Elections Commission
State Election Agency
Defendant in DOJ lawsuit; facing intervention by voting rights groups

Wisconsin's bipartisan state election agency responsible for administering elections and maintaining voter registration records.

ACLU Voting Rights Project
ACLU Voting Rights Project
Legal Advocacy Organization
Intervening in multiple state lawsuits to protect voter privacy

The national ACLU's voting rights litigation team, working to block DOJ's voter data collection efforts across multiple states.

ACLU of Connecticut
ACLU of Connecticut
Legal Advocacy Organization
Intervened in Connecticut lawsuit to protect voter privacy

The Connecticut affiliate of the ACLU, working to block DOJ access to voter data in the state.

CH
Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA)
Legal Advocacy Organization
Filed Oct 31 court filing challenging the DOJ-flagged California voter list with UCLA analysts

A Los Angeles immigrant-rights group that filed, with UCLA's Voting Rights Project, a court challenge to the DOJ's California list of possible noncitizen voters.

Timeline

May 2017 November 2026

51 events Latest: November 11th, 2026 · 1 week ago Showing 8 of 51
Tap a bar to jump to that date
  1. Georgia Senate Votes to Pressure Raffensperger

    Political

    Republican-controlled Georgia Senate passes resolution 31-22 along party lines urging Secretary of State Raffensperger to turn over unredacted voter list containing 8 million voters' personal information to DOJ. Nonbinding resolution opposed by Raffensperger and Democrats. Raffensperger says office will not violate state law protecting voters' SSNs, driver's license numbers, and birth dates.

  2. Senate Democrats Demand DOJ Cease Pressure Campaign

    Political

    Senators Padilla and Durbin lead 28 Senate Democrats in sending letter to Attorney General Bondi demanding DOJ stop its "unlawful pressure campaign" to obtain voter data and raise alarm about Minnesota coercion attempt. Letter seeks written responses by February 12 and briefing by February 26.

  3. Bondi Conditions ICE Withdrawal on Minnesota Data

    Political

    Attorney General Bondi sends letter to Minnesota Governor Walz hours after ICE fatally shot Alex Pretti, demanding voter rolls and welfare data as condition for removing ICE/CBP from Minneapolis. Minnesota Secretary of State Simon rejects demand as "outrageous attempt to coerce" state, calling it violation of state and federal law.

  4. Georgia Senate Targets Raffensperger

    Political

    Georgia Senate Ethics Committee passes resolution demanding Secretary of State Raffensperger turn over unredacted voter data to DOJ.

  5. First Commission Disbanded

    Background

    Trump disbands the commission without it ever receiving state voter data or issuing findings. No evidence of widespread fraud was found.

  6. First Commission Requests Voter Data

    Background

    Kobach asks every state for voter information including Social Security numbers. 44 states and D.C. refuse some or all data.

  7. Trump Creates First Voter Fraud Commission

    Background

    President Trump signs executive order creating the Presidential Advisory Commission on Election Integrity, chaired by Vice President Pence with Kris Kobach as vice chair.

Scenarios

1

Supreme Court Sides with DOJ, States Must Comply

Possible

Discussed by: Legal analysts at SCOTUSblog and election law scholars anticipating appeals from California and Oregon rulings

If the Supreme Court accepts appeals and rules that the Civil Rights Act of 1960's records inspection provision applies to state voter files, all 50 states would be required to provide unredacted voter rolls to federal authorities. DOJ would gain access to sensitive data for approximately 160 million registered voters, which it plans to cross-reference with DHS databases to identify alleged non-citizens.

2

Courts Block Campaign, States Retain Control

Possible

Discussed by: The Brennan Center for Justice, ACLU, and voting rights advocates who cite the California and Oregon dismissals as indicators

Federal appeals courts uphold the California and Oregon dismissals, finding the Civil Rights Act of 1960 was never intended to authorize mass collection of voter data. Other district courts follow the precedent. DOJ's litigation campaign stalls without Supreme Court intervention. States that refused to comply maintain control of their voter files, and the effort mirrors the fate of the 2017 commission.

3

Mixed Rulings Create Patchwork Compliance

Likely

Discussed by: Election administration experts tracking divergent rulings from Trump and Obama-appointed judges

Federal judges split along ideological lines. Trump-appointed judges in some districts, like Connecticut, order states to comply. Clinton and Obama appointees dismiss cases. The result is a patchwork where some states provide data and others don't, creating an incomplete federal database and prolonged circuit-level litigation before potential Supreme Court review.

4

States Preemptively Change Laws to Block Data Sharing

Possible

Discussed by: State legislators and secretaries of state in Democratic-led states considering statutory changes

States pass or strengthen laws explicitly prohibiting the release of sensitive voter data to federal authorities without specific statutory authorization. This fortifies state defenses against future demands regardless of court outcomes but sets up a longer-term federalism battle over election administration authority.

5

Appeals Court Pauses Voter Policy Vacatur, DOJ Resumes Demands

Unlikely Resolves by End of 2026

Discussed by: Legal analysts tracking the D.C. Circuit appeal

If the D.C. Circuit grants DOJ's request to pause the October 9 vacatur, DOJ could resume demanding voter files and running them against federal databases. States that already complied would face renewed pressure.

Historical Context

3 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

May 2017 - January 2018

Presidential Advisory Commission on Election Integrity (2017-2018)

President Trump created a commission chaired by Vice President Mike Pence and Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach to investigate alleged voter fraud. Kobach requested voter data including Social Security numbers from all 50 states. 44 states and D.C. refused some or all information.

Then

Trump disbanded the commission in January 2018 after it received no state voter data, faced multiple lawsuits, and generated bipartisan backlash. Commission member Matthew Dunlap later revealed it found no evidence of widespread fraud.

Now

The commission's failure demonstrated that states—including Republican-led states—would resist federal voter data collection on privacy and federalism grounds. The current DOJ effort uses litigation rather than voluntary requests to overcome that resistance.

Why this matters now

The 2017 commission and the current DOJ campaign seek the same data for similar stated purposes. The key difference: DOJ now uses federal lawsuits citing the Civil Rights Act to compel compliance rather than relying on voluntary cooperation.

1960-1965

Civil Rights Act of 1960 and Voter Records Inspection

Congress passed the Civil Rights Act of 1960 to expose racist voter registration practices in the Jim Crow South. Title III required election officials to preserve voting records for 22 months and produce them upon written demand by the Attorney General. The provision helped prove that registrars applied different standards to Black and white applicants.

Then

Over 16 months, Attorneys General William Rogers and Robert Kennedy inspected voting records in 26 Southern counties. Records revealed white applicants passed literacy tests that illiterate white citizens didn't take, while Black applicants faced impossible standards.

Now

Evidence gathered under the 1960 Act helped build the case for the Voting Rights Act of 1965. The records inspection provision was designed for targeted investigations of discrimination—not mass collection of voter data nationwide.

Why this matters now

DOJ's current use of this 1960 provision to demand unredacted voter files from all states inverts its original purpose. Judge Carter called this 'using civil rights legislation which was enacted for an entirely different purpose' to centralize voter data.

2012-Present

Judicial Watch NVRA Lawsuits (2010s-Present)

The conservative legal group Judicial Watch has filed numerous lawsuits against states and counties for allegedly failing to remove ineligible voters from rolls under the National Voter Registration Act. Settlements resulted in Los Angeles County agreeing to remove up to 1.6 million inactive registrations and Ohio implementing a challenged cleanup program upheld by the Supreme Court in 2018.

Then

States and counties entered consent decrees requiring more aggressive voter roll maintenance. Critics argued the settlements pressured officials into removing eligible voters.

Now

These private lawsuits established legal precedent that NVRA compliance could be enforced through litigation. The DOJ's current campaign represents a federal government version of this approach, but with far broader scope and access demands.

Why this matters now

The DOJ effort escalates the private NVRA enforcement model to federal scale. While Judicial Watch sought to force states to purge voters, DOJ seeks the underlying data to identify purge targets directly.

Sources

(68)