Pull to refresh
Logo
Israel uploaded millions of Palestinian photos to Amazon's facial recognition system

Israel uploaded millions of Palestinian photos to Amazon's facial recognition system

Force in Play

Leaked documents show a military department ran 3.5 million images through Amazon Rekognition under a 2021 cloud contract.

Overview

Updated 58 minutes ago

In early 2024, an Israeli military department called Rolling Stone uploaded 3.5 million photographs of Palestinians to Amazon's cloud. It ran them through Rekognition, Amazon's facial recognition service. The images came from a database built over decades, including ID photos taken when Palestinians turn 16.

The upload was not a rogue act. Project Nimbus, a 2021 contract, makes Amazon and Google the cloud backbone of Israel's government and military. The contract bars the companies from suspending service, even if Israel violates their terms.

Why it matters

If a cloud contract can bar Amazon from cutting off a military's facial-recognition use, the same template can travel to other governments.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

3.5 million
Photos uploaded to Amazon Rekognition
Images of Palestinians moved to AWS cloud in early 2024.
2
US cloud providers under Project Nimbus
Amazon Web Services and Google share the 2021 contract.
16
Age Palestinians receive ID cards
ID photos form part of the Rolling Stone database.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

Organizations Involved

Timeline

2021 November 2026

9 events Latest: Today
Tap a bar to jump to that date
  1. Microsoft disables Israeli military access

    Corporate action

    After a Guardian and +972 investigation, Microsoft cuts off access to a mass surveillance system.

  2. 3.5 million photos uploaded

    Surveillance

    Rolling Stone moves the images to Amazon Rekognition for facial recognition analysis.

  3. Soldiers work from AWS offices

    Surveillance

    A small Israeli military group studies facial recognition use from AWS's Tel Aviv offices on the 28th floor.

  4. Hamas-led attack triggers Gaza war

    Conflict

    Israel launches bombardment and ground invasion; image collection at checkpoints expands.

  5. AWS opens Israeli data centers

    Infrastructure

    New facilities let Israeli government and military clients move data from their own servers.

  6. Rolling Stone moves data to AWS

    Data transfer

    The department shifts a large share of its Palestinian database into an isolated zone in AWS's Tel Aviv cloud.

  7. Project Nimbus signed

    Contract

    Amazon Web Services and Google win a contract to provide cloud services to Israel's government and military.

Scenarios

1

Congress opens inquiry into AWS's Nimbus role

Possible Resolves by Q2 2027

Discussed by: Human rights groups and some US lawmakers have called for scrutiny of Project Nimbus; no formal inquiry has been announced.

The revelation prompts a congressional committee or federal regulator to request documents from Amazon about its Israeli military work. An inquiry could lead to hearings, but the Nimbus contract limits what Congress can force.

2

Human rights groups sue Amazon over facial recognition data

Possible Resolves by End of 2027

Discussed by: Palestinian and international human rights organizations have documented the surveillance; litigation is a common next step.

A rights group or group of Palestinian plaintiffs files suit in US or Israeli court, arguing the data transfer violates privacy or human rights law. The Nimbus contract's unusual clauses would be a central obstacle.

3

Nimbus continues unchanged as contract shields Amazon

Likely Resolves by End of 2027

Discussed by: The Guardian's reporting on Nimbus clauses suggests the contract is designed to prevent suspension.

Amazon and Google keep providing cloud services to the Israeli military. The contract's clauses barring suspension even for terms-of-service violations hold. No public consequence follows the revelation.

Historical Context

3 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

1933-1945

IBM and Nazi Germany (1933-1945)

IBM's German subsidiary supplied punch-card machines and tabulating equipment to Nazi Germany. The machines helped the regime process census data, identify Jews, and organize deportations and train schedules.

Then

IBM maintained the relationship through the war; the equipment was used in the machinery of the Holocaust.

Now

The case became a landmark example of how commercial data-processing infrastructure can be repurposed for persecution, and it shaped later debates over corporate complicity.

Why this matters now

The Amazon case raises the same structural question: what responsibility does a company bear when its data tools are used by a state against a civilian population?

2025

Microsoft and Israel's Unit 8200 (2025)

The Guardian and +972 Magazine revealed that Microsoft's Azure cloud hosted a mass surveillance system built by Israel's Unit 8200, storing data on Palestinians. Microsoft later disabled the military's access to the technology.

Then

Microsoft cut off access, a rare instance of a cloud provider restricting a military client.

Now

The episode showed that a cloud provider can suspend access, and highlighted that the Nimbus contract is written to prevent exactly that.

Why this matters now

The contrast is direct: Microsoft acted unilaterally, while Amazon's Nimbus contract contains clauses barring similar suspension.

2021-2024

Google and Amazon worker protests over Nimbus (2021-2024)

After Project Nimbus was signed, Google and Amazon employees protested, citing the contract's role in Israeli surveillance. Google fired several workers who staged sit-ins.

Then

The protests drew attention to the contract but did not stop it.

Now

The firings became a test case for worker organizing against military cloud contracts.

Why this matters now

The internal dissent shows that the companies' own employees saw the surveillance risk early, before the 2026 revelation made it public.

Sources

(8)